Monday, February 3, 2014

116 Largest US REITs Stock Prices Down 61% Due to Financial Meltdown Spillover Effects, Then Up 308% Under Obama and the US Fed

I found 116 US Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) classified in the Financial Sector at Yahoo's superb Finance website with current Total Market Capitalizations of at least $100 mil each and which also had their common stocks trading on each of the following three dates:


  • On December 31, 2007 during President Bush's second term
  • On March 6, 2009, very early in President Obama's first term, which was their lowest point due to the spillover effects resulting from the 2008 financial meltdown, and 
  • also on the most recent date January 31, 2014.

The historical common stock prices of these companies were obtained from the following two excellent internet resources....  Google Finance and MarketWatch Big Charts.

These 116 US REITs had their average stock prices drop by a massive 61% from December 31, 2007 during President Bush's second Presidential term, to March 6, 2009, very early in President Obama's first term, which was the very lowest point for the overall stock market due to the spillover effects resulting from the disastrous 2008 Financial Meltdown.

But since March 6, 2009, the average stock prices of these same 116 US REITs have increased by a very impressive 308% through January 31, 2014.  In real total return terms, the average stock price increase of 308% is markedly understated because it excludes the cash dividends that these REITs paid out. 


The REIT Hotel Subsector led the pack here with an average stock market price appreciation for the less than five years since March 6, 2009 of a spectacular 601%.

In addition, three other REIT Subsectors had their average stock market prices more than triple, as follows: REIT Diversified up 394%, REIT Industrials up 382% and REIT Retail up 331%.

All seven REIT Subsectors experienced average stock price increases since March 6, 2009 of more than 100%.

The lowest stock price increase in the REIT Hotel Subsector was a very healthy 286%. 

There were four of these 116 US REITs with stock market price increases of more than 10 times since March 6, 2009, led by Newcastle Investment Corp, up a massive 34 times.

Only 4 of these 116 US REITs experienced stock market price declines since March 6, 2009.

In all fairness, the investors in and employees of a clear majority of these these 116 US REITs should be extremely pleased with the very positive impact of actions taken by both the Obama Administration and the US Fed to successfully rescue the US economy from its extremely weakened state caused by the disastrous 2008 US financial meltdown.

The 2008 financial meltdown crushed all US Real Estate and thus it only follows that the US Real Estate Investment Trust sector would plunge.  What the Obama Administration and the US Fed did to resurrect the US Real Estate market from the dead was nearly miraculous.

But yet there are still many REIT executives and REIT stockholders who give the US Government little if any credit for this.  This cannot be an objective assessment.

Below here are the stock market prices of each of these 116 US REITs on January 31, 2014, on March 6, 2009, and on December 31, 2007, broken down first by REIT Subsector and then sorted by Percentage Increase from March 6, 2009 to January 31, 2014:






Market Market






Price Price






% %






Change Change



 Market   Market   Market  3-6-09 12-31-07



 Price   Price   Price  to to
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)

 1-31-14   3-6-09   12-31-07  1-31-14 3-6-09





Diversified






Newcastle Investment Corp New York NY      5.44      0.15      6.08 3416% -97%
iStar New York NY    15.42      1.09    26.05 1315% -96%
Gramercy Property Trust New York NY      5.82      0.51    24.31 1041% -98%
Arbor Realty Trust Uniondale NY      6.87      0.65    16.11 957% -96%
One Liberty Properties Great Neck NY    20.86      2.39    16.16 772% -85%
Lexington Realty Trust New York NY    10.81      1.99    12.88 442% -85%
RAIT Financial Trust Philadelphia PA      8.44      1.83    25.86 361% -93%
Brandywine Realty Trust Radnor PA    14.25      3.53    17.93 304% -80%
Douglas Emmett Inc Santa Monica CA    25.43      6.45    22.61 294% -71%
Corrections Corp America Nashville TN    33.57      9.82    29.51 242% -67%
WP Carey New York NY    59.08    18.02    33.20 228% -46%
Public Storage Glendale CA  157.59    48.83    73.41 223% -33%
Vornado Realty Trust New York NY    91.83    29.31    87.95 213% -67%
American Tower Boston MA    80.88    27.28    42.60 196% -36%
Blackstone Mortgage Trust New York ny    28.06    10.10  306.50 178% -97%
Gladstone Commercial McLean VA    18.65      6.79    17.54 175% -61%
PS Business Parks Glendale AZ    78.57    30.21    52.55 160% -43%
National Retail Properties Orlando FL    33.20    12.96    23.38 156% -45%
Winthrop Realty Trust Boston MA    11.48      6.06    26.45 89% -77%
Cousins Properties Inc Atlanta GA    10.75      5.81    20.56 85% -72%
UMH Properties Freehold NJ      9.45      5.25    11.77 80% -55%
Redwood Trust Mill Valley CA    18.70    12.45    34.24 50% -64%
MFA Financial New York NY      7.29      5.32      9.25 37% -42%
Capstead Moertage Corp Dallas TX    12.62      9.49    13.19 33% -28%
Chimera Investment Corp New York NY      3.12      2.50    17.88 25% -86%
Investors Real Estate Trust Minot ND      8.69      8.77      8.97 -1% -2%
Anworth Mortgage Asset Santa Monica CA      4.69      5.54      8.26 -15% -33%
Annaly Capital Management New York NY    10.77    12.88    18.18 -16% -29%
Average % Change all 28




394% -64%








Healthcare Facilities






Medical Properties Trust Birmingham AL    13.27      3.04    10.19 337% -70%
Sabra Health Care REIT Irvine CA    28.93      8.24    17.17 251% -52%
Ventas Chicago IL    62.39    20.41    45.25 206% -55%
National Health Investors Murfreesboro TN    62.97    21.84    27.90 188% -22%
The GEO Group Boca Raton FL    33.48    11.75    28.00 185% -58%
Omega Healthcare Investors Hunt Valley MD    31.94    11.89    16.05 169% -26%
HCP Inc Long Beach CA    39.15    16.08    34.78 143% -54%
LTC Properties Westlake Village CA    37.95    16.74    25.05 127% -33%
Health Care REIT Toledo OH    57.92    27.27    44.69 112% -39%
Healthcare Realty Trust Inc Nashville TN    22.92    12.78    25.39 79% -50%
Universal Health Realty Income King of Prussia PA    42.40    25.93    35.44 64% -27%
Average % Change all 11




169% -44%








Hotels/Motels






Strategic Hotels & Resorts Chicago IL      9.31      0.77    16.73 1109% -95%
FelCor Lodging Trust Irving TX      8.16      0.94    15.59 768% -94%
Ryman Hospitality Properties Nashville TN    41.36      4.99    40.47 729% -88%
LaSalle Hotel Properties Bethesda MD    30.76      3.91    31.90 687% -88%
Sunstone Hotel Investors Aliso Viejo CA    12.83      2.11    18.29 508% -88%
Host Hotels & Resorts Bethesda MD    18.39      3.54    17.04 419% -79%
Hersha Hospitality Trust Philadelphia PA      5.43      1.35      9.50 302% -86%
Diamondrock Hospitality Bethesda MD    11.58      3.00    14.98 286% -80%
Average % Change all 8




601% -87%








Industrial






CubeSmart Malvern PA    16.48      1.50      9.16 999% -84%
Extra Space Storage Salt Lake City UT    45.66      5.18    14.29 781% -64%
First Industrial Realty Trust Chicago IL    17.16      2.51    34.60 584% -93%
Prologis San Francisco CA    38.76      9.72    57.56 299% -83%
Sovran Self Storage Williamsville NY    67.91    17.10    40.10 297% -57%
Duke Realty Indianapolis IN    15.71      4.48    26.08 251% -83%
BioMed Realty Trust San Diego CA    19.51      6.98    23.17 180% -70%
EastGroup Properties Jackson MS    59.34    21.54    41.85 175% -49%
DCT Industrial Trust Denver CO      7.20      2.64      9.31 173% -72%
Monmouth Real Estate Investment Freehold NJ      9.24      5.09      8.10 82% -37%
Average % Change all 10




382% -69%








Office






Boston Properties Boston MA  108.09    31.73    91.81 241% -65%
Kilroy Realty Los Angeles CA    52.80    15.52    54.96 240% -72%
CommonWealth REIT Newton MA    24.58    10.88    30.92 126% -65%
Highwoods Properties Raleigh NC    37.14    16.72    29.38 122% -43%
Liberty Property Trust  Malvern PA    36.40    16.95    28.81 115% -41%
Alexandria Real Estate Equities Pasadena CA    70.13    32.83  101.67 114% -68%
First Potomac Realty Trust Bethesda MD    13.06      6.46    17.29 102% -63%
Parkway Properties Orlando FL    17.74      9.11    36.98 95% -75%
Digital Realty Trust San Francisco CA    50.99    26.33    38.37 94% -31%
Mack-Cali Realty Edison NJ    20.23    14.63    34.00 38% -57%
Corporate Office Properties Trust Columbia MD    24.85    21.72    31.50 14% -31%
Franklin Street Properties Wakefield MA    11.99    10.80    14.80 11% -27%
Average % Change all 12




109% -53%








Residential






Sun Communities Southfield MI    46.75      7.71    21.07 506% -63%
Apartment Investment & Management Denver CO    27.97      4.94    29.11 466% -83%
Post Properties Atlanta GA    46.93    10.15    35.12 362% -71%
UDR Inc Highlands Ranch CO    24.34      7.23    19.85 237% -64%
Equity Residential Chicago IL    55.38    17.09    36.47 224% -53%
BRE Properties San Francisco CA    59.10    18.28    40.53 223% -55%
Education Realty Trust Memphis TN      9.03      2.86    11.24 216% -75%
Associated Estates Realty Richmond Heights OH    15.97      5.35      9.44 199% -43%
Avalonbay Communities Arlington VA  123.50    42.14    94.14 193% -55%
Essex Property Trust Palo Alto CA  158.37    55.19    97.49 187% -43%
Resource Capital Corp New York NY      5.89      2.07      9.31 185% -78%
Mid-America Apartment Communities Memphis TN    64.54    23.71    42.75 172% -45%
Equity LifeStyle Properties Chicago IL    39.31    15.29    22.84 157% -33%
American Campus Communities Austin TX    34.76    15.61    26.85 123% -42%
Home Properties Rochester NY    55.75    25.36    44.85 120% -43%
Senior Housing Properties Trust Newton MA    22.52    11.39    22.68 98% -50%
Dynex Capital Glen Allen VA      8.06      6.90      8.87 17% -22%
Two Harbors Investment Minnetonka MN      9.83      8.77      8.38 12% 5%
ARMOUR Residential REIT Vero Beach FL      4.11      9.53      9.05 -57% 5%
Average % Change all 19




192% -48%








Retail






SL Green Realty New York NY    93.77      8.69    93.46 979% -91%
NorthStar Realty Finance New York NY    14.59      1.39      8.92 950% -84%
DDR Corp Beachwood OH    15.67      1.52    38.29 931% -96%
Macerich Santa Monica CA    56.60      6.79    67.32 733% -90%
CBL & Associates Properties Chattanooga TN    16.99      2.09    23.91 713% -91%
Glimcher Realty Trust Columbus OH      8.56      1.08    14.29 693% -92%
Pennsylvania REIT Philadelphia PA    18.65      2.47    29.68 655% -92%
Simon Property Group Indianapolis IN  154.84    26.19    86.86 491% -70%
Taubman Centers Bloomfield Hills MI    65.02    13.56    49.19 379% -72%
Ramco-Gershenson Properties Trust Farmington Hills MI    15.97      3.88    21.37 312% -82%
EPR Properties Kansas City MO    51.08    12.79    47.00 299% -73%
Weingarten Realty Investors Houston TX    28.99      8.43    31.44 244% -73%
Kimco Realty New Hyde Park NY    20.91      7.01    36.40 198% -81%
Hospitality Properties Trust Newton MA    25.70      9.09    32.22 183% -72%
Federal Realty Investment Trust Rockville MD  109.00    39.90    82.15 173% -51%
Realty Income Escondido CA    40.78    15.03    27.02 171% -44%
Tanger Factory Outlet Centers Greensboro NC    33.38    13.20    18.86 153% -30%
Alexander's Paramus NJ  339.83  137.82  353.25 147% -61%
Equity One North Miami Beach FL    22.66      9.74    23.03 133% -58%
Saul Centers Bethesda MD    46.60    20.44    53.43 128% -62%
Kite Realty Group Trust Indianapolis IN      6.45      2.93    15.27 120% -81%
Regency Centers Jacksonville FL    48.14    22.02    64.49 119% -66%
Cedar Realty Trust Port Washington NY      6.31      3.32    10.23 90% -68%
Urstadt Biddle Properties Greenwich CT    18.76    10.37    15.50 81% -33%
Inland Real Estate Oak Brook IL    10.54      6.12    14.16 72% -57%
Retail Opportunity Investments San Diego CA    14.46      9.50      9.17 52% 4%
Washington REIT Rockville MD    23.30    15.60    31.41 49% -50%
Getty Realty Jericho NY    19.00    14.30    26.68 33% -46%
Average % Change all 28




331% -67%








Overall Average % Change all 116




308% -61%