Monday, March 17, 2014

Washington State Non-Profit Hospitals Net Assets Up 81% Under Obama and the Affordable Care Act

From a review of the Electronic Municipal Market Access (EMMA), I found 8 Non-Profit Hospital Organizations headquartered in the State of Washington with Net Assets (i.e. Financial Strength or Total Assets minus Total Liabilities) at the most recent date reported of more than $400 mil each.  Below here are the Net Assets of these 8 at both the most recent reported date and also at the Fiscal Year End (FYE) closest to the beginning of the Obama Administration:






FYE Balance Net




Most
Balance Sheet Assets



Most Recent
Sheet Net %



Recent Balance
Date Assets Change



Balance Sheet
Beginning Beginning During
City State Sheet Net
Obama Obama Obama
Hospital Organization HQs HQs Date Assets
Admin Admin Admin




mil $s

mil $s









Providence Health Renton WA Dec 13     7,317
Dec 08       3,911 87%
Seattle Children's Healthcare Seattle WA Dec 13     1,914
Sep 09       1,195 60%
MultiCare Health System Tacoma WA  Mar 14      1,815
Dec 08          650 179%
PeaceHealth Vancouver WA Dec 13     1,709
Jun 09          897 91%
Univ Washington Med Center Seattle WA Jun 13        669
Jun 09          495 35%
Harborview Medical Center Seattle WA Jun 13        622
Jun 09          662 -6%
Virginia Mason Medical Center Seattle WA Dec 13        408
Dec 08          195 109%
Overlake Hospital Association Bellevue WA Dec 13        406
Jun 09          199 104%









Total all 8


  14,860

      8,204 81%

As you can see from the above chart, the Total Net Assets (Financial Strength) of these 8 Washington Non-Profit Hospital Organizations increased by a spectacular 81% to $14.860 bil during their average 4.56 years so far of the Obama Administration.

Very positively impacting this major increase in the Net Assets (Financial Strength) of these 8 Washington Hospitals were actions taken by both the Obama Administration and the US Fed to strengthen the US Financial Foundation which was severely damaged from the financial meltdown in late 2008.

In addition, the Affordable Care Act (ACA) has also played a key role in this increase in Net Assets (Financial Strength) of these 8 Washington Non-Profit Hospital Organizations.

A remarkable thing is that these robust increases in Net Assets (Financial Strength) of these Non-Profit Hospital Organizations occurred when these Non-Profit Hospitals were also playing very instrumental roles in the substantial annual percentage growth reduction of Total US Health Care Costs which occurred in each of the most recent three years under the ACA.

With such substantial Net Asset percentage increases of these 8 Washington Hospitals, a key beneficiary of this will be Washington citizens electing to buy health insurance on the Health Insurance Exchange.  This exceptional Net Asset growth gives these Washington Hospitals the financial flexibility to moderate their pricing for hospital procedures in their negotiations with health insurance companies which ultimately determines what insurance premium prices are set at by health insurance companies on the Health Insurance Exchange.  

Washington State Struggling Hospitals

The State of Washington is being very transparent with its citizens by having available for review annually at its Health Information website very detailed financial information on each of its individual Hospitals.  The most recent financial information is for 2012.

There were 86 Washington Hospitals which had Operating Results shown at the Washington website in either 2012 or 2011.  These 86 Washington Hospitals had Total Operating Income of $844 mil in their most recent fiscal year shown which was a very respectable 5.0% of their Total Operating Revenues of $16.736 bil.  And these 86 Washington Hospitals' Total Operating Income of $844 mil was burdened with an Earnings Charge of $936 mil due to Total Provisions for Bad Debts.  In addition, their Total Uncompensated Charity Care Costs were quite huge.

But you have to stratify these Hospitals to find out what is really going on with Washington Hospitals.

First, let's look at the upper end Washington Hospitals.  There were 15 Washington Hospitals generating an Operating Income Margin of higher than 9.5%.  These 15 High Profit Washington Huskies generated a Total Operating Income Margin of an obscene 13.4%.

But on the downside, there were 21 Washington Hospitals which had Operating Losses and another 18 with very modest Operating Income Margins of 0.0% to 2.5%.

Below here are these 86 Washington Huskies:


Most 

Operating


Recent Operating Total Income


Year Income Operating (Loss)
Hospital Name City HQs End (Loss) Revenues Margin


mil $s mil $s %
Pure Golden Washington Husky Hospitals



Navos Seattle 2012             2.7           10.6 25.5%
Mary Bridge Children's Hospital Tacoma 2012           51.5         209.4 24.6%
BHC Fairfax Hospital Kirkland Dec 11             5.2           30.4 17.1%
St. Elizabeth Hospital Enumclaw 2012             7.6           50.5 15.0%
Capital Medical Center Olympia Dec 11           11.7           84.5 13.8%
Seattle Children's Hospital Seattle 2012         128.3         949.7 13.5%
Saint Joseph Medical Center Tacoma 2012           79.7         600.1 13.3%
Kindred Hospital Seattle Seattle Dec 11             2.7           20.6 13.1%
Swedish Medical Center-Cherry Hill Seattle 2012           47.0         361.7 13.0%
Providence Mount Carmel Hospital Colville 2012             4.9           40.3 12.2%
Tacoma General Allenmore Hospital Tacoma 2012           76.7         672.4 11.4%
Saint Francis Community Hospital Federal Way 2012           20.6         189.6 10.9%
Yakima Regional Medical & Cardiac Ctr Yakima 2012           12.1         122.9 9.8%
Valley Hospital Spokane 2012             9.8         102.0 9.6%
Odessa Memorial Hospital Odessa 2012             0.7             7.3 9.6%






Total all 15 Pure Golden Huskies

        461.2      3,452.0 13.4%






In-The-Middle Washington Husky Hospitals




Kadlec Medical Center Richland 2012           23.4         312.4 7.5%
PeaceHealth Saint Joseph Hospital Bellingham 2012           30.5         423.1 7.2%
Samaritan Hospital Moses Lake 2012             4.5           62.9 7.2%
Jefferson Healthcare Port Townsend 2012             4.9           69.5 7.1%
Providence Holy Family Hospital Spokane 2012           12.5         179.7 7.0%
University of Washington Medical Center Seattle 2012           59.1         877.6 6.7%
Providence Sacred Heart Medical Center Spokane 2012           50.1         745.3 6.7%
Sunnyside Community Hospital Sunnyside 2012             3.2           48.6 6.6%
Seattle Cancer Care Alliance Seattle 2012           21.9         346.6 6.3%
Dayton General Hospital Dayton 2012             0.7           11.2 6.3%
MultiCare Good Samaritan Hospital Puyallup 2012           23.0         380.1 6.1%
Cascade Valley Hospital Arlington 2012             2.6           44.1 5.9%
Whitman Hospital & Medical Center Colfax 2012             1.4           23.9 5.9%
PeaceHealth Saint John Med Center Longview Jun 11           14.2         247.3 5.7%
Mason General Hospital Shelton 2012             4.1           72.4 5.7%
Providence Saint Mary Medical Center Walla Walla Dec 11             6.8         120.9 5.6%
Wenatchee Valley Hospital Wenatchee Dec 11             5.1           98.1 5.2%
Toppenish Community Hospital Toppenish 2012             1.1           21.2 5.2%
Kittitas Valley Hospital Ellensburg 2012             3.1           60.1 5.2%
Saint Luke's Rehab Institute Spokane 2012             2.0           39.0 5.1%
Saint Anthony Hospital Gig Harbor 2012             4.8         100.9 4.8%
Legacy Salmon Creek Vancouver 2012             9.1         200.7 4.5%
Overlake Hospital Medical Center Bellevue 2012           18.1         413.1 4.4%
Saint Clare Hospital Tacoma 2012             5.5         127.0 4.3%
Quincy Valley Hospital Quincy 2012             0.5           12.2 4.1%
Skyline Hospital White Salmon 2012             0.6           19.2 3.1%
Skagit Valley Hospital Mount Vernon 2012             7.6         246.5 3.1%
Virginia Mason Hospital Seattle 2012           28.1         954.8 2.9%
Pullman Regional Hospital Pullman 2012             1.4           48.7 2.9%
Summit Pacific Medicaln Center Elma 2012             0.3           10.7 2.8%
Providence Centralia Hospital Centralia Dec 11             3.7         134.4 2.8%
Central Washington Hospital Wenatchee 2012             5.5         205.0 2.7%






Total all In-The-Middle Huskies

        359.4      6,657.2 5.4%






Loss or Low Profit Husky Hospitals




Providence Saint Peter Hospital Olympia Dec 11             9.5         379.2 2.5%
Harrison Medical Center Bremerton 2012             8.6         345.2 2.5%
Harborview Medical Center Seattle 2012           18.1         765.8 2.4%
Swedish Medical Center Seattle Dec 11           23.1      1,030.8 2.2%
PeaceHealth Southwest Medical Center Vancouver 2012           10.6         514.8 2.1%
Tri-State Memorial Hospital Clarkston 2012             1.1           57.6 1.9%
Lake Chelan Community Hospital Chelan 2012             0.4           21.1 1.9%
Kennewick General Hospital Kennewick Dec 11             2.6         141.1 1.8%
EvergreenHealth Kirkland 2012             8.2         471.8 1.7%
Snoqualmie Valley Hospital Snoqualmie 2012             0.4           25.2 1.6%
Coulee Community Hospital Grand Coulee Dec 11             0.3           23.9 1.3%
Morton General Hospital Morton 2012             0.2           22.5 0.9%
Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital Yakima 2012             2.9         352.5 0.8%
Swedish Edmonds Edmonds 2012             1.5         197.1 0.8%
Providence Regional Med Ctr-Everett Everett 2012             3.9         551.1 0.7%
Newport Community Hospital Newport 2012             0.1           23.7 0.4%
Island Hospital Anacortes 2012             0.3           79.8 0.4%
Olympic Medical Center Port Angeles 2012             0.1         133.5 0.1%
Lourdes Medical Center Pasco 2012            (0.6)           86.2 -0.7%
Three Rivers Hospital Brewster 2012            (0.1)           12.4 -0.8%
Lourdes Counseling Center Richland 2012            (0.2)           14.8 -1.4%
Providence Saint Joseph's Hosp-Chewelah Chewelah Dec 11            (0.3)           20.1 -1.5%
Deaconess Hospital Spokane Dec 11            (5.4)         244.0 -2.2%
Northwest Hospital Seattle 2012            (6.1)         259.3 -2.4%
Lincoln Hospital Davenport Dec 11            (0.5)           21.2 -2.4%
Mid-Valley Hospital Omak 2012            (0.8)           28.3 -2.8%
North Valley Hospital Tonasket Dec 11            (0.6)           20.3 -3.0%
Valley Medical Center Renton 2012            (7.3)         217.8 -3.4%
Cascade Medical Center Leavenworth 2012            (0.5)           12.7 -3.9%
Grays Harbor Community Hospital Aberdeen 2012            (5.0)         103.0 -4.9%
Regional Hosp for Respirator&Complex Care Burien Dec 11            (1.1)           20.1 -5.5%
Klickitat Valley Hospital Goldendale 2012            (1.1)           17.5 -6.3%
Garfield County Memorial Hospital Pomeroy Dec 11            (0.4)             6.3 -6.3%
United General Hospital Sedro-Woolley 2012            (3.5)           39.7 -8.8%
Highline Medical Center Seattle Dec 11          (18.2)         197.3 -9.2%
Columbia Basin Hospital Ephrata 2012            (1.2)           12.9 -9.3%
Valley General Hospital Monroe Dec 11            (4.5)           45.2 -10.0%
MultiCare Auburn Regionl Medical Ctr Auburn 2012          (10.7)         106.7 -10.0%
East Adams Rural Hospital Ritzville 2012            (0.7)             4.7 -14.9%






Total all 39 Low Profit or Loss Huskies

          23.1      6,627.2 0.3%




             -  
Total all 86 Washington Husky Hospitals

       843.7     16,736.4 5.0%

At first glance, an overall Total Operating Margin of 5.0% seems very positive for Washington Hospitals.

But when 21 of these 86 Washington Hospitals had Operating Losses and 39 of them, or 45% of them, posted Operating Income of a very modest 2.5% or less, there is a financial quality problem with Washington Hospitals that must be fixed.

By far the best and only economically good way to put a major dent in the Operating Losses of the many struggling Washington Hospitals is for the State of Washington to fully expand Medicaid, which it wisely has done.  Since Washington did this, there will be a resultant massive inflow of Patient Revenues from Medicaid expansion, after all there were $936 mil of Total Provisions for Bad Debts Charges that reduced the Total Operating Revenues of all Washington Hospitals in their most recent year shown.  In addition, there were huge Uncompensated Charity Care Costs in that same year.

With this massive inflow of Revenues due to Medicaid expansion in Washington, the struggling Washington Hospitals will be able to substantially reduce their Operating Losses and a huge majority of them should even be able to turn their losses into profits.  And due to Medicaid expansion, the Washington Hospitals with very modest Operating Income will have their profits bolstered very robustly, as will the Washington Hospitals now making higher than modest Operating Income.

Also since Washington fully expanded Medicaid, another key beneficiary of the resultant very healthy profit improvement and thus also Total Net Assets improvement of all Washington Hospitals will be the Washington citizens electing to buy health insurance on the Health Insurance Exchange.  This exceptional Net Asset growth from Medicaid expansion should in all fairness give all Washington Hospitals the financial flexibility to moderate their pricing for hospital and other health care procedures in their negotiations with health insurance companies which ultimately determines what insurance premium prices are set at by health insurance companies on the Health Insurance Exchange.