Thursday, May 10, 2012

New York Corporate 2011 Annual Earnings Up Sharply Under Obama

I found 95 Corporations…..35 Financial and 60 Non-Financial….., headquartered in New York, which file with the SEC, and which had Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of more than $200 mil in any of the most recent three fiscal years. 

The 35 Financial New York Corps generated Total Pretax Income in 2011 of $85.0 bil, down 14% from 2010, but up an incredible 121% over 2009.

The $13.6 bil decline in Pretax Profit of these Financial Corps in 2011 as compared with 2010 was caused by profit declines of two large investment banking firms: Merrill Lynch of $8.6 bil and Goldman Sachs of $6.7 bil.

The $46.6 bil increase in Pretax Profit of these Financial Firms in 2011 as compared with 2009 was caused mainly by huge profit increases by three large financial firms: Citigroup of $24.8 bil, AIG of $15.0 bil, and JPMorgan Chase of $10.6 bil.

The 60 Non-Financial New York Corps generated Total Pretax Income in 2011 of a  massive $133.3 bil, up 11% from 2010, and up a more robust 30% over 2009.

In deriving Pretax Income, I start with Pretax Income under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), and then exclude several clearly unusual very large items relative to Pretax Income, such as Asset Impairments, Gains and Losses on both Debt Retirements and Asset Dispositions, Special Litigation Charges and Gains.  In addition, I am excluding Derivative Gains and Losses of MetLife and MBIA.

New York citizens should be extremely proud of the operating performance in the most recent two years of the overwhelming majority of their fine New York Corporations. 

Clearly, the Obama Administration has created an economic environment that has permitted these New York Corporations to flat-out flourish. 

I think the only way to ensure that these fine Non-Financial New York Corps will be able to generate Total Pretax Earnings growth for the remainder of 2012 of at least 10%, and at the same time, also result in very robust US job creation, is for the US Congress to immediately pass the following economic initiatives:

  • Extend the 100% first-year tax expensing of equipment and computer software investments made in the remainder of 2012.  The CBO-scored cost should not be very significant.
  • Substantially accelerate first-year tax depreciation on all new building and building remodeling investments made in the remainder of 2012, and rein in its CBO-scored cost, by lowering tax depreciation in years 2 through 10.
  • Pass the Research and Experimentation Tax Credit for businesses for all 2012 expenditures, but substantially enhance it, especially for smaller businesses, and simplify it.
  • Give small businesses, creating US jobs in 2012, a 10% tax credit.
  • Give businesses a 20% income tax credit for the expenses of moving operations from overseas back to the US.  And pay for this by removing income tax deductions businesses now get for moving their production from the US to overseas.  This one's pretty cool, where the pay-for is also positive to the US job count.
  • Permit US taxpayers, who have their mortgage loans financed by either Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, to have their mortgages refinanced at the current lower prevailing market interest rates.  
  • Pass the substantial amount of school construction infrastructure fix ups for K-12 Schools and for Community Colleges, which is in the American Jobs Act (AJA).  And all of these school investments should occur in 2012, and mostly from now through the end of the summer of 2012.

The above first two will result in explosive US economic stimulation, particularly when viewed in light of future business income tax reform, which should result in a much lower business income tax rate in 2013 and going forward.

Thus, businesses will get both the 100% first-year tax depreciation on equipment purchases and the substantially accelerated first-year tax deprecation on building investments in 2012 at a business income tax rate reduction which is much higher in 2012, and then the future earnings from these equipment and building investments will generate post 2012 earnings streams from these investments which are taxed at a much lower post tax reform business income tax rate.  Wow, now that is bold economic stimulation.

This above bold economic stimulation effectively works like a back-door, stealth investment tax credit in 2012, due to the expected future reduction in business income tax rates starting in 2013 under any reasonable business tax reform. 

The investment tax credit was used first by President Jack Kennedy in the early 1960s to get the US out of a deep recession.  And President Lyndon Johnson also used it after he took over.  The end result was US real GDP growth which averaged 4.85% from 1960 to 1968.  And the US unemployment rate dropped substantially while this investment tax credit was in effect during the 1960s

This kind of very robust US real GDP growth, markedly north of 4%, and for an extended period of time, is precisely what the US economy now needs.  And this very strong GDP growth is by far the best way to substantially reduce the massive US Deficit.  

But these explosive economic benefits to US businesses from this accelerated first-year tax depreciation does not necessarily mean that there will be resultant substantial US job creation from it.

Thus, I would make sure that the largest of the US Corps…..say the top 50 or so…..would get these first-year accelerated tax depreciation benefits in 2012 only if they add a sufficient number of US full-time workers in 2012.

And similar economic benefits will result from the Research and Experimentation Expenditures.  Not only will businesses get higher Research Tax Credits in 2012 for making investments in 2012, but they will also get 2012 tax deductions from these Research investments made in 2012 at the higher business income tax rate in 2012, and then subsequently get the future earnings stream from these Research investments taxed at the lower post tax reform business income tax rate that will be applicable starting in 2013 and going forward.

Below here is the Pretax Income (PTI) and Pretax Loss (PTL) of these 95 New York Corps for each of the most recent three years, with the most recent fiscal year ends ranging from March 2011 to February 2012.






Obama





Bump




PTI(L) PTI(L)

1 Year 2 Year

PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) % %

2011 2010 2009 Change Change
mils $s mils $s mils $s

New York 




Financial




JPMorgan Chase 26,749 24,859 16,067 8% 66%
Citigroup 14,624 13,184 (10,199) 11% 243%
American Express 6,956 5,964 2,841 17% 145%
Goldman Sachs 6,169 12,892 19,829 -52% -69%
Morgan Stanley 6,114 6,231 1,130 -2% 441%
MetLife 5,202 4,177 505 25% 930%
Bank NY Mellon 3,617 3,694 (2,208) -2% 264%
MasterCard 3,516 2,757 2,218 28% 59%
BlackRock 3,135 3,021 1,272 4% 146%
AIG 1,917 273 (13,036) 602% 115%
Marsh & McLennan 1,404 1,169 1,109 20% 27%
Travelers 1,352 4,306 4,711 -69% -71%
M&T Bank 1,225 1,093 519 12% 136%
Assured Guaranty 1,034 549 117 88% 784%
Moodys 840 714 646 18% 30%
NY Community Bancorp 735 837 453 -12% 62%
NYSE Euronext 725 686 205 6% 254%
Assurant 715 912 793 -22% -10%
HSBC USA 682 1,445 (265) -53% 357%
Nasdaq OMX Group 573 526 391 9% 47%
MBIA 573 674 (267) -15% 315%
Arch Capital Group 427 850 898 -50% -52%
Jefferies Group 419 397 508 6% -18%
Broadridge Fincl Solutions 270 342 346 -21% -22%
Signature Bank 267 176 104 52% 157%
First Niagara 262 212 120 24% 118%
Lazard Ltd 235 244 (182) -4% 229%
Amtrust Fincl Services 229 171 132 34% 73%
Alleghany 191 277 395 -31% -52%
ETrade Fincl 185 (3) (816) 6267% 123%
XL Group 8 685 135 -99% -94%
Transatlantic (215) 473 596 -145% -136%
Platinum Underwriters (227) 259 388 -188% -159%
Everest Re Group (234) 591 939 -140% -125%
Merrill Lynch (4,694) 3,923 7,989 -220% -159%
Total all 35 Financial 84,980 98,560 38,383 -14% 121%






Non Financial




IBM 21,003 19,723 18,138 6% 16%
Verizon 16,448 15,739 14,957 5% 10%
Pfizer 14,438 13,136 10,780 10% 34%
Phillip Morris Intl 12,532 10,324 9,243 21% 36%
PepsiCo 8,834 8,232 8,079 7% 9%
Bristol Myers Squibb 6,981 6,071 5,602 15% 25%
Time Warner 4,366 3,919 3,237 11% 35%
News Corp 4,177 3,323 2,161 26% 93%
Colgate Palmolive 3,582 3,701 3,538 -3% 1%
Corning 3,343 3,521 1,934 -5% 73%
Hess 3,248 2,935 1,522 11% 113%
Viacom 3,245 2,838 2,417 14% 34%
Time Warner Cable 2,462 2,196 1,912 12% 29%
Loews 2,232 2,902 2,766 -23% -19%
CBS 2,083 1,222 653 70% 219%
Omnicom Group 1,549 1,350 1,274 15% 22%
McGraw-Hill 1,347 1,331 1,182 1% 14%
Forest Labs 1,338 951 971 41% 38%
L-3 Communications 1,328 1,484 1,386 -11% -4%
Coach 1,301 1,158 983 12% 32%
CA 1,209 1,152 1,049 5% 15%
Estee Lauder 1,026 688 343 49% 199%
Avon Products 1,006 945 914 6% 10%
Bunge Ltd 940 610 145 54% 548%
Polo Ralph Lauren 825 689 588 20% 40%
Paychex 792 729 704 9% 13%
Leucadia National 681 369 (241) 85% 383%
Tiffany 665 547 390 22% 71%
Interpublic Group 612 451 257 36% 138%
Vornado Realty 604 562 119 7% 408%
Constellation Brands 572 575 362 -1% 58%
Henry Schein 569 502 453 13% 26%
Starwood Hotel 495 300 140 65% 254%
Weight Watchers 483 313 290 54% 67%
Cablevision Systems 479 479 386 0% 24%
Xylem 470 388 277 21% 70%
Sirius XM Radio 441 168 (78) 163% 665%
Foot Locker 435 257 73 69% 496%
PVH 432 217 212 99% 104%
Pall Corp 420 328 271 28% 55%
Jarden 419 250 314 68% 33%
Intl Flavors & Fragrances 374 360 277 4% 35%
National Fuel Gas 372 356 339 4% 10%
MSC Industrial Direct 349 241 202 45% 73%
Towers Watson 327 170 222 92% 47%
Ascena Retail 284 209 102 36% 178%
Veeco Instruments 272 297 1 -8% 27100%
MSCI 263 153 132 72% 99%
AMC Networks 232 206 159 13% 46%
Sothebys 231 226 15 2% 1440%
Iconix Brand Group 213 163 117 31% 82%
Nielsen Holdings 206 (6) (16) 3533% 1388%
BP Prudhoe Bay Royalty 201 184 158 9% 27%
Warnaco Group 168 230 169 -27% -1%
Atlas Air WW 157 233 124 -33% 27%
SL Green Realty 136 142 67 -4% 103%
Aeropostale 113 387 383 -71% -70%
ITT 78 (276) (208) 128% 138%
AOL 42 339 460 -88% -91%
Liz Claiborne (148) (90) (234) -64% 37%
Total all 60 Non Financial 133,282 120,099 102,172 11% 30%






Total all 95 218,262 218,659 140,555 0% 55%



And lastly, let me combine all Financial Corps HQed in all US States, which generated a Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of more than $1 bil each in any of the four years from 2008 to 2011.

Altogether, there were 67 of these Financial Corps.

Now let me summarize the Total Pretax Income or Total Pretax Loss in each of these years for all of these 67 Financial Corps.

2008…..Total Pretax Loss… .$242 bil
2009…..Total Pretax Loss….…$50 bil
2010…..Total Pretax Income $147 bil
2011…..Total Pretax Income $164 bil

The magnitude of this 2008 Total Pretax Loss of $242 bil clearly shows that the US was headed for a complete financial meltdown, with a resultant depression.  And this $242 bil Total Loss in 2008 was understated since some of these financial institutions, including Fannie Mae, were late in recording many of their massive Credit Losses until after 2008.  And on top of these massive 2008 Losses, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac had more than $1 trillion of their debt held as Investments by Financial Institutions, Non-Financial Corporations, Mutual Funds, Pension Funds, and other Investors, and both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were bankrupt, and with massive future annual losses continuing ad infinitum.

But by wise actions by both the Obama Administration and the Fed, this massive Total Loss of $242 bil in 2008 was reduced to a Total Loss of $50 bil in 2009, and then reversed course, and resulted in a Total Profit of $147 bil in 2010 and a higher Total Profit of $164 bil in 2011.

It just amazes me how so many people are still enraged at the Obama Administration and the Fed for taking actions to rescue the Financial Industry.

The above numbers don’t lie.  The Obama Administration and the Fed saved the country from a sure depression.  And US financial institutions, investors, and all US citizens should be very thankful mainly to Barack Obama, to Tim Geithner and to Ben Bernanke for their near miraculous actions.

Below here is the Pretax Income or Pretax Loss from 2008 through 2011 for each of these 67 Financial Giant Corps.




PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L)


2008 2009 2010 2011


mils $s mils $s mils $s mils $s






AIG NY (103,029) (13,036) 273 1,917
Fannie Mae DC (44,570) (73,007) (14,100) (16,945)
Freddie Mac VA (44,564) (22,384) (14,882) (5,666)
Citigroup NY (42,413) (10,199) 13,184 14,624
Merrill Lynch NY (42,076) 7,989 3,923 (4,694)
Ally Financial MI (7,891) (6,909) 1,139 67
Hartford Financial Services CT (3,846) (1,721) 2,356 230
HSBC Finance US IL (3,695) (8,784) (3,903) (3,734)
Allstate IL (3,025) 1,248 1,126 960
HSBC USA NY (2,676) (265) 1,445 682
Legg Mason MD (1,880) 330 365 303
Fifth Third Bancorp OH (1,699) (991) 940 1,831
Santander Holdings US PA (1,634) (1,123) 1,019 1,523
MBIA NY (1,507) (267) 674 573
ETrade Financial NY (1,279) (816) (3) 185
Prudential Financial NJ (1,226) 1,524 4,392 5,117
First Data GA (1,186) (1,506) (1,288) (760)
MGIC Investment WI (948) (1,765) (359) (484)
Radian Group PA (674) (242) (1,580) 369
CIT Group NJ (608) (3,411) 779 325
CNA Financial IL (562) 540 1,112 877
Ameriprise Financial MN (423) 920 1,634 1,385
Key Corp OH (381) (2,057) 793 1,345
Toyota Motor Credt CA (380) (1,052) 1,679 3,003
Huntington Bancshares OH (296) (1,071) 352 707
Progressive OH (222) 1,557 1,565 1,487
Synovus Financial GA (181) (1,606) (849) (60)
SLM DE (34) 272 1,433 927
Zions Bancorp UT 39 (1,557) (403) 521
Regions Financial AL 67 (1,268) (844) 414
Assured Guaranty NY 112 117 549 1,034
Lincoln National PA 244 209 1,234 1,346
Unionbancal CA 412 (226) 793 1,081
M&T Bank NY 740 519 1,093 1,225
SunTrust Banks GA 740 (1,699) 21 739
Discover Financial Services IL 794 229 1,269 3,511
T Rowe Price MD 796 689 1,070 1,251
Unum Group TN 824 1,292 1,331 257
Aon IL 879 949 1,059 1,384
Marsh & McLennan NY 921 1,109 1,169 1,404
BlackRock NY 1,016 1,272 3,021 3,135
PNC Financial PA 1,094 2,149 4,061 4,069
MetLife NY 1,149 505 4,177 5,202
Western Union CO 1,239 1,132 1,145 1,275
CME Group IL 1,248 1,438 1,722 1,937
Interactive Brokers CT 1,250 538 337 741
Morgan Stanley NY 1,254 1,130 6,231 6,114
TD Ameritrade NE 1,264 1,059 912 1,016
Northern Trust IL 1,276 1,255 990 884
Capital One Financial VA 1,393 1,336 4,330 4,587
ACE Ltd PA 1,567 3,077 3,667 2,091
AFLAC GA 1,914 2,235 3,585 2,992
Bank NY Mellon NY 1,946 (2,208) 3,694 3,617
Charles Schwab CA 2,028 1,276 1,099 1,392
BB&T NC 2,079 1,036 969 1,628
MasterCard NY 2,100 2,218 2,757 3,516
Franklin Resources CA 2,248 1,289 2,070 2,624
Goldman Sachs NY 2,336 19,829 12,892 6,169
Chubb NJ 2,407 2,962 2,988 2,199
JPMorgan Chase NY 2,773 16,067 24,859 26,749
Visa CA 2,806 3,527 4,638 5,656
State Street Corp MA 2,842 2,525 2,086 2,536
Wells Fargo CA 3,300 17,998 19,001 23,656
American Express NY 3,581 2,841 5,964 6,956
Travelers MN 3,716 4,711 4,306 1,352
US Bancorp MN 4,099 2,632 4,200 6,629
Bank of America NC 4,428 (3,629) 7,154 7,648
GE Capital CT 6,157 (2,467) 2,225 7,660






Total all 67
(241,827) (49,736) 146,640 164,291






Obama/Geithner/Bernanke Bump
...By year

192,091 196,376 17,651
...Total



406,118