Thursday, May 10, 2012

Michigan Corporate 2011 Annual Earnings Up $71 Bil Since 2009

I found 29 Corporations, headquartered in Michigan, which file with the SEC, and which had Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of more than $100 mil in any of the most recent three fiscal years.

These 29 Michigan Corps, led by Autos Big Three: GM, Ford and Chrysler, improved their Pretax Earnings by a massive $71 bil in the most recent two years, going from a Pretax Loss of $39.6 bil in 2009 to a Pretax Profit of $31.7 bil in 2011.  Whew!

In deriving Pretax Income, I start with Pretax Income under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), and then exclude several clearly unusual very large items relative to Pretax Income, such as Asset Impairments, Gains and Losses on both Debt Retirements and Asset Dispositions, and Special Litigation Charges and Gains.

Michigan citizens should be extremely proud of the operating performance in the most recent two years of their superb Michigan Corporations. 

Clearly, the Obama Administration has created an economic environment in the past two years that has permitted these Michigan Corporations to flat out flourish. 

And both Michigan members in the US Senate…..Debbie Stabenow and Carl Levin, what a strong duo Michigan is blessed with…..have been a great help in fostering the operating success of these fine Michigan companies…..what fighters these two are.

And the following Michigan members in the US House…..John Dingell, John Conyers, Sander Levin, Hansen Clarke, Dale Kildee and Gary Peters…..have all been strong advocates for these fine Michigan companies.

With this off-the-charts $71 bil Pretax Earnings turnaround in the most recent two years, which includes very strong Pretax Earnings growth of 23% in 2011 over 2010, there is no way that this robust 23% total earnings growth in 2011 will continue in 2012. 

And this earnings growth has markedly decelerated in the 1Q of 2012.

I think the only way to ensure that these fine Michigan Corps will generate total earnings growth for the remainder of 2012 of at least 15% to 20%, and at the same time, also result in very robust US job creation, is for the US Congress to immediately pass the following economic initiatives:

  • Extend the 100% first-year tax expensing of equipment and computer software investments made in the remainder of 2012.  The CBO-scored cost should not be very significant.
  • Substantially accelerate first-year tax depreciation on all new building and building remodeling investments made in the remainder of 2012, and rein in its CBO-scored cost, by lowering tax depreciation in years 2 through 10.
  • Pass the Research and Experimentation Tax Credit for businesses for all 2012 expenditures, but substantially enhance it, especially for smaller businesses, and simplify it.
  • Give small businesses, creating US jobs in 2012, a 10% tax credit.
  • Give businesses a 20% income tax credit for the expenses of moving operations from overseas back to the US.  And pay for this by removing income tax deductions businesses now get for moving their production from the US to overseas.  This one's pretty cool, where the pay-for is also positive to the US job count.
  • Permit US taxpayers, who have their mortgage loans financed by either Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, to have their mortgages refinanced at the current lower prevailing market interest rates.  
  • Pass the substantial amount of school construction infrastructure fix ups for K-12 Schools and for Community Colleges, which is in the American Jobs Act (AJA).  And all of these school investments should occur in 2012, and mostly from now through the end of the summer of 2012.

The above first two will result in explosive US economic stimulation, particularly when viewed in light of future business income tax reform, which should result in a much lower business income tax rate in 2013 and going forward.

Thus, businesses will get both the 100% first-year tax depreciation on equipment purchases and the substantially accelerated first-year tax deprecation on building investments in 2012 at a business income tax rate reduction which is much higher in 2012, and then the future earnings from these equipment and building investments will generate post 2012 earnings streams from these investments which are taxed at a much lower post tax reform business income tax rate.  Wow, now that is bold economic stimulation.

This above bold economic stimulation effectively works like a back-door, stealth investment tax credit in 2012, due to the expected future reduction in business income tax rates starting in 2013 under any reasonable business tax reform. 

The investment tax credit was used first by President Jack Kennedy in the early 1960s to get the US out of a deep recession.  And President Lyndon Johnson also used it after he took over.  The end result was US real GDP growth which averaged 4.85% from 1960 to 1968.  And the US unemployment rate dropped substantially while this investment tax credit was in effect during the 1960s

This kind of very robust US real GDP growth, markedly north of 4%, and for an extended period of time, is precisely what the US economy now needs.  And this very strong GDP growth is by far the best way to substantially reduce the massive US Deficit.  

But these explosive economic benefits to US businesses from this accelerated first-year tax depreciation does not necessarily mean that there will be resultant substantial US job creation from it.

Thus, I would make sure that the largest of the US Corps…..say the top 50 or so…..would get these first-year accelerated tax depreciation benefits in 2012 only if they add a sufficient number of US full-time workers in 2012.

And similar economic benefits will result from the Research and Experimentation Expenditures.  Not only will businesses get higher Research Tax Credits in 2012 for making investments in 2012, but they will also get 2012 tax deductions from these Research investments made in 2012 at the higher business income tax rate in 2012, and then subsequently get the future earnings stream from these Research investments taxed at the lower post tax reform business income tax rate that will be applicable starting in 2013 and going forward.

Below here is the Michigan headquarters location of each of these 29 Michigan Corporations. 

Michigan Corporation Michigan HQs


Ford Motor Dearborn
GM Detroit
Dow Chemical Midland
Kellogg Battle Creek
Stryker Kalamazoo
Delphi Automotive plc Troy
TRW Automotive Livonia
Chrysler Auburn Hills
BorgWarner Auburn Hills
Lear Southfield
Perrigo Allegan
Visteon Van Buren Township
Credit Acceptance Southfield
Penske Automotive Bloomfield Hills
Gentex Zeeland
Federal Mogul Southfield
Valassis Communications Livonia
Wolverine WW Rockford
Dominos Pizza Ann Arbor
Meritor Troy
Compuware Detroit
Syntel Troy
Con-way Ann Arbor
American Axle Detroit
Whirlpool Benton Harbor
Herman Miller Zeeland
Ally Financial Detroit
Masco Taylor
PulteGroup Bloomfield Hills

And below here is the Pretax Income (PTI) and Pretax Loss (PTL) of these 29 Michigan Corps for each of the most recent three years, with the most recent fiscal year ends ranging from March 2011 to December 2011.





Obama





Bump




PTI(L) PTI(L)

1 Year 2 Year

PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) % %

2011 2010 2009 Change Change
mils $s mils $s mils $s

Michigan




Ford Motor 8,681 7,993 (2,067) 9% 520%
GM 7,253 5,541 (24,473) 31% 130%
Dow Chemical 3,917 2,677 (422) 46% 1028%
Kellogg 1,732 1,742 1,684 -1% 3%
Stryker 1,686 1,729 1,624 -2% 4%
Delphi Automotive 1,506 944 (1,129) 60% 233%
TRW Automotive 1,188 1,041 140 14% 749%
Chrysler 932 (513) (8,095) 282% 112%
Borg Warner 766 478 18 60% 4156%
Lear 616 449 (229) 37% 369%
Perrigo 451 309 206 46% 119%
Visteon 371 318 169 17% 120%
Credit Acceptance 296 253 229 17% 29%
Penske Automotive 248 189 123 31% 102%
Gentex 244 203 96 20% 154%
Federal Mogul 241 179 (55) 35% 538%
Valassis Communications 196 167 101 17% 94%
Wolverwine WW 169 143 86 18% 97%
Dominos Pizza 168 139 80 21% 110%
Meritor 159 76 (52) 109% 406%
Compuware 155 157 213 -1% -27%
Syntel 154 134 135 15% 14%
Con-way 148 36 45 311% 229%
American Axle 138 119 (297) 16% 146%
Whirlpool 131 735 356 -82% -63%
Herman Miller 103 35 99 194% 4%
Ally Financial 67 1,139 (6,909) -94% 101%
Masco 22 (43) 126 151% -83%
PulteGroup (69) (579) (1,412) 88% 95%






Total all 29 31,669 25,790 (39,610) 23% 180%