San Antonio, Texas-Based Pipe Lines Company NuStar Energy LP's Top-Tier Executives Average Pay Raise Was a Clean, Very Robust 17.6% Per Year During the Past Ten Years (2009-2018)

From annual compensation information contained in Company 10-K and Proxy Statement filings with the US SEC, the chart below shows NuStar Energy LP's Top-Tier Executives Annual Total Compensation for each of two consecutive full years of employment for the past ten years.

	FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE
	Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec
NuStar Energy LP	2018	2017		2017	2016		2016	2015		2015	2014		2014	2013
Top-Tier	Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total
Executive	Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp
	$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s
Barron CEO	3,501	2,091		2,091	2,518		2,518	2,476		2,476	2,407		2,407	1,007
Shoaf CFO	1,516	1,109		1,109	1,232		1,232	1,230		1,230	1,375		1,375	1,448
Brown Chief Administrative Officer	1,515	1,229		1,229	1,335		1,335	1,448		1,448	1,463		1,463	1,076
Perry EVP Mergers & Acquisitions & Strategy	1,133	697		697	787		787	795		795	832
Oliver SVP Marketing	1,113	877
Thompson SVP General Counsel							797	796		796	864
Totals	8,778	6,003		5,126	5,872		6,669	6,745		6,745	6,941		5,245	3,531
Annual % Change vs Prior Year	46.2%			-12.7%			-1.1%			-2.8%			48.5%
5 Year Average Per Year % Change		15.6%
	FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE
	Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec
NuStar Energy LP	2013	2012		2012	2011		2011	2010		2010	2009		2009	2008
Top-Tier	Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total
Executive	Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp
	$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s
Barron CEO	1,007	963		963	916
Shoaf CFO	N/A	N/A
Brown Chief Administrative Officer	1,076	1,027		1,027	1,014		1,014	944		944	783
Anastasio Former CEO	4,691	2,172		2,172	2,382		2,382	2,113		2,113	1,816		1,816	1,769
Blank Former CFO	2,379	1,148		1,148	1,254		1,254	1,116		1,116	930		930	1,002
Comeau EVP	N/A	N/A
Bluntzer EVP Operations							1,174	1,032		1,032	897		897	854
Brattlof SVP Supply and Trading										849	723
Totals	9,153	5,310		5,310	5,566		5,824	5,205		6,054	5,149		3,643	3,625
Annual % Change vs Prior Year	72.4%			-4.6%			11.9%			17.6%			0.5%
5 Year Average Per Year % Change		19.5%
10 Year Average Per Year % Change		17.6%