Houston, Texas-Based Plains All America Pipeline LP's Top-Tier Executives Average Pay Raise Was a Robust 10.4% Per Year During the Past Ten Years (2009-2018): a Negative 2.9% Per Year For the Most Recent Five Years and a Positive 23.7% Per Year For the Earlier Five Years

From annual compensation information contained in Company Proxy Statement and 10-K filings with the US SEC, the chart below shows Plains All America Pipeline LP's Top-Tier Executives Annual Total Compensation for each of two consecutive full years of employment for the past ten years.

	FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE
	Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec
Plains All America Pipeline LP	2018	2017		2017	2016		2016	2015		2015	2014		2014	2013
Top-Tier	Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total
Executive	Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp
	$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s
Armstrong Former CEO	N/A	N/A		43	43		43	392		392	4,292		4,292	7,454
Chiang CEO	8,893	3,307		3,307	2,810		N/A	N/A
Pefanis Chief Commercial Officer	1,917	367		367	317		317	317		317	4,117		4,117	6,963
Swanson CFO	3,264	2,065		2,065	2,394		2,394	1,167		1,167	1,917		1,917	3,842
Nerbonne EVP Ops and Engineering	3,331	2,068		2,068	2,381
McGee General Counsel	2,846	2,065		2,065	3,533
vonBerg EVP				2,275	2,092		2,092	3,917		3,917	4,442		4,442	6,853
Duckett CEO Canada										2,987	3,604		3,604	6,042
Totals	20,251	9,872		12,190	13,570		4,846	5,793		8,780	18,372		18,372	31,154
Annual % Change vs Prior Year	105.1%			-10.2%			-16.3%			-52.2%			-41.0%
5 Year Average Per Year % Change		-2.9%
	FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE		FYE	FYE
	Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec		Dec	Dec
Plains All America Pipeline LP	2013	2012		2012	2011		2011	2010		2010	2009		2009	2008
Top-Tier	Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total		Total	Total
Executive	Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp		Comp	Comp
	$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s		$ 000s	$ 000s
Armstrong Former CEO	7,454	5,591		5,591	5,391		5,391	9,509		9,509	3,391		3,391	3,290
Chiang CEO
Pefanis Chief Commercial Officer	6,963	5,316		5,316	5,116		5,116	7,362		7,362	3,216		3,216	3,115
Swanson CFO	3,842	2,266		2,266	2,016		2,016	3,339		3,339	1,642		1,642	895
vonBerg EVP	6,853	6,581		6,581	5,486		5,486	4,337		4,337	3,486		3,486	2,955
Duckett CEO Canada	6,042	4,482		4,482	4,413		4,413	5,119		5,119	3,713		3,713	3,272
Totals	31,154	24,236		24,236	22,422		22,422	29,666		29,666	15,448		15,448	13,527
Annual % Change vs Prior Year	28.5%			8.1%			-24.4%			92.0%			14.2%
5 Year Average Per Year % Change		23.7%
10 Year Average Per Year % Change		10.4%