Wednesday, October 3, 2018

The Ohio Market Areas of Columbus, Cincy/Dayton, Toledo and Akron All Underperformed on the Earnings Front in 2017, Trump's First Year in Office .......................................................................................

From a review of US SEC filings, I found 17 Columbus Area, 18 Cincinnati/Dayton Area, 4 Toledo Area and 2 Akron Area Non-Utility Companies with stock market caps of more than $1 Bil recently.

These 4 Ohio Market Areas Underperformed on the earnings front in Fiscal Year Ended (FYE) 2017. Trump's first year in office.

The 17 Columbus Area Cos Generated Total Audited US GAAP Pretax Income From Continuing Operations in FYE Ended 2017 which declined by a substantial 28% from that in 2016.  In contrast, these 17 Columbus Area Cos experienced a much lower earnings decline in 2016 of 3% and positive earnings growth of 8% in 2015. 

The 18 Cincinnati/Dayton Area Cos Generated Total Audited US GAAP Pretax Income From Continuing Operations in FYE Ended 2017 which declined by 0.6% from that in 2016.  In 2016, this earnings growth was 0.3% and in 2015 this earnings growth was 8%.

The 4 Toledo Area Cos Generated Total Audited US GAAP Pretax Income From Continuing Operations in FYE Ended 2017 which declined by a substantial 20% from that in 2016.  In sharp contrast, these 4 Toledo Area Cos experienced an earnings growth in 2016 of 19%, followed by earnings growth of an even better 42% in 2015.

The 2 Akron Area Cos Generated Total Audited US GAAP Pretax Income From Continuing Operations in FYE Ended 2017 which declined by a substantial 27% from that in 2016.  In very sharp contrast, these 2 Akron Area Cos experienced an earnings growth in 2016 of an exceptional 52%.

My Focus is on Pretax Income Rather Than on After-Tax Net Income Because Income Taxes are Simply a Transfer of Financial Wealth Between US Corporations and the US Federal, US State and Foreign Governments.  It Has Nothing Whatsoever to do with Company Operating Performance.

From a review of SEC filings, the chart below shows the Audited Gold-Standard US GAAP Pretax Income (Loss) From Continuing Operations for the Fiscal Years Ended 2017, 2016, 2015 and 2014 for these 41 Ohio Non-Utility Companies with stock market caps above $1 Bil recently.

Trump Obama
First Last Obama Obama
Year Year Year Year
2017 2016 2015 2014
Audited Audited Audited Audited
Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax
Income Income Income Income
(Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss)
Ohio Non-Utility Companies From From From From
Undeperforming Market Areas in 2017 City State 2017 Continuing Continuing Continuing Continuing
Stock Market Caps Above $1 Bil HQs HQs FYE Operations Operations Operations Operations
 $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils
Columbus Area Companies
Huntington Bancorp Columbus OH Dec 17              1,394                 920                 914                 853
L Brands Columbus OH Jan 18              1,312              1,696              1,934              1,636
Mettler-Toledo Columbus OH Dec 17                 574                 504                 463                 445
Scott's Miracle Gro Marysville OH Sep 17                 315                 384                 205                 226
Big Lots Columbus OH Dec 17                 295                 244                 227                 222
Washington Prime Group Columbus OH Dec 17                 232                   77               (104)                 205
Worthington Industries Columbus OH May 18                 209                 297                 217                 113
Greif Delaware OH Oct 17                 198                 140                 114                 156
Lancaster Colony Westerville OH Jun 18                 174                 176                 185                 155
DSW Inc Columbus OH Jan 18                 127                 203                 220                 246
Park National Newark OH Dec 17                 118                 123                 114                 120
Wendy's Dublin OH Dec 17                 101                 202                 234                 193
Advanced Draining Systems Hilliard OH Mar 18                   76                   61                   54                     3
Installed Building Products Columbus OH Dec 17                   56                   60                   42                   23
Abercrombie & Fitch New Albany OH Jan 18                   55                   (3)                   55                   99
State Auto Financial Columbus OH Dec 17                   33                   19                   67                   27
Cardinal Health Dublin OH Jun 18               (228)              1,924              2,276              1,967
Total all 17 Columbus Area Cos              5,041              7,027              7,217              6,689
………. % Change From Preceding Year
-28%
-3% 8%
Cincinnati/Dayton Area Cos
Procter & Gamble Cincinnati OH Jun 18            13,326            13,257            13,369            11,012
Fifth Third Bancorp Cincinnati OH Dec 17              2,771              2,065              2,365              2,028
Macy's Cincinnati OH Jan 18              1,507                 952              1,678              2,390
Kroger Cincinnati OH Jan 18              1,484              2,914              3,094              2,649
Cintas Cincinnati OH May 18                 841                 687                 705                 641
Worldpay Symmes Township OH Dec 17                 814                 423                 297                 235
Cincinnati Financial Fairfield OH Dec 17                 730                 812                 881                 721
American Financial Group Cincinnati OH Dec 17                 724                 787                 565                 626
Convergys Cincinnati OH Dec 17                 180                 186                 177                 129
Chemed Cincinnati OH Dec 17                 117                 177                 180                 163
First Financial Bancorp Cincinnati OH Dec 17                 116                 131                 111                   95
Teradata Dayton OH Dec 17                   58                 221               (144)                 494
Medpace Holdings Cincinnati OH Dec 17                   57                   22                   (8)                 (21)
Multi-Color Batavia OH Mar 18                   54                   88                   67                   71
AK Steel West Chester OH Dec 17                   51                   61               (383)                 (26)
Milacron Holdings Cincinnati OH Dec 17                   18                   45                 (18)                     7
Air Transport Services Group Wilmington OH Dec 17                   (7)                   34                   63                   52
EW Scripps Cincinnati OH Dec 17                 (32)                   93               (112)                     9
Total all 18 Cincy/Dayton Area Cos            22,809            22,955            22,887            21,275
………. % Change From Preceding Year -1% 0% 8%
Toledo Area Companies
Welltower Toledo OH Dec 17                 561              1,063                 895                 511
Owens-Corning Toledo OH Dec 17                 559                 587                 454                 231
Dana Inc Maumee OH Dec 17                 399                 229                 258                 273
Owens-Illinois Perrysburg OH Dec 17                 275                 356                 268                 307
Total all 4 Toledo Area Companies              1,794              2,235              1,875              1,322
………. % Change From Preceding Year -20% 19% 42%
Akron Area Companies
Goodyear Tire & Rubber Akron OH Dec 17                 878              1,207                 608                 687
Signet Jewelers Ltd Akron OH Jan 18                 527                 714                 658                 541
Total 2 Akron Area Companies              1,405              1,921              1,266              1,228
………. % Change From Preceding Year -27% 52% 3%