Thursday, October 18, 2018

Michigan Auto and Auto Parts Companies Total Pretax Earnings Were Down the Tubes in the First Half of 2018, With Their Total Pretax Earnings Declining By 22%. GM's Pretax Earnings Were Down By 31% and Ford's Were Down By 28%.

......................................................................
As a Comparison, in Barack Obama's Last Year in Office in 2016, the Detroit, Michigan Area Companies Total Pretax Earnings Growth in 2016 Was 3% Over That in Annual 2015, and Total Pretax Earnings Growth in 2015 Was an Exceptional 72% Over That in Annual 2014   
......................................................................
And Detroit Area Companies Had Their Total Annual Pretax Earnings Increase By $61.2 Bil From Total Pretax Losses of $30.9 Bil in 2009 to Total Pretax Income of $30.3 Bil in 2016 and By an Even Higher $73.8 Bil From Total Pretax Losses of $43.5 Bil in 2008 to Total Pretax Income of $30.3 Bil in 2016
......................................................................
And in Barack Obama's Last Year in Office in 2016, All Michigan Companies Total Pretax Earnings Growth in 2016 Was 4% Over That in Annual 2015, and Total Pretax Earnings Growth in 2015 Was an Exceptional 61% Over That in Annual 2014   
......................................................................
From a review of US SEC filings, there were 44 Companies headquartered effectively in Michigan with stock market caps of more than $1 Bil recently.

Of these 44 Michigan Cos, 16 are in the Motor Vehicles and Parts Industry.

My focus is on Pretax Income rather than on After-Tax Net Income because Income Taxes are simply a transfer of financial wealth between US Corporations and the US Federal, US State and Foreign Governments.  It has nothing whatsoever to do with Company Operating Performance.

From a review of SEC filings, the chart below shows the Gold-Standard US GAAP Pretax Income (Loss) From Continuing Operations for the First Half of 2018 and 2017 for these 44 Michigan Companies.

US US
GAAP GAAP
Pretax Pretax
Income Income
(Loss) (Loss)
6 Months 6 Months
June June Better
July July (Worse)
Michigan Companies or Aug or Aug %
Market Caps Above $1 Bil 2018 2017  Change
mils $ mils $
Motor Vehicle and Parts Cos
General Motors              4,461              6,440 -31%
Ford Motor              3,268              4,517 -28%
Lear Corp                 905                 808
Aptiv plc                 761                 592
BorgWarner                 647                 583
Autoliv                 439                 401
WABCO Holdings                 266                 205
Gentex                 261                 263
American Axle                 260                 155
Delphi Technologies plc                 237                 220
Meritor                 177                   99
Visteon                 137                 133
Cooper-Standard Holdings                 121                 116
Gentherm                   36                   44
Veoneer                 (93)                 (30)
Adient plc               (111)                 513 -122%
Total all 16 Motor Vehicle and Parts Cos            11,772            15,059 -22%
Cos in all Other Sectors
DowDuPont              3,910              2,942 33%
Kellogg              1,180                 694 70%
Stryker              1,165                 943 24%
Ally Financial                 789                 702
DTE Energy                 674                 736
Masco                 512                 472
CMS Energy                 446                 435
Credit Acceptance Corp                 356                 301
Penske Automotive Group                 320                 282
Domino's Pizza                 195                 180
Perrigo Co plc                 166                   20
Chemical Financial                 164                 135
Wolverine World Wide                 123                   43
Syntel                 118                   99
Flagstar                 106                 100
Universal Forest Products                 102                   85
Steelcase                   90                   79
Herman Miller                   84                   95
La-Z-Boy                   70                   60
Taubman Centers                   65                   61
Sun Communities                   58                   43
TriMas                   57                   35
Neogen                   37                   36
Agree Realty                   30                   30
Altair Engineering                     7                 (11)
Diplomat Pharmacy                   (4)                     9
Esperion Therapeutics                 (92)                 (84)
Whirlpool               (500)                 410 -222%
Total 28 Cos in all Other Sectors            10,228              8,933 15%
Total all 44 Michigan Companies            22,000            23,992 -8%

Also from a review of SEC filings, the chart below shows the Gold-Standard US GAAP Pretax Income (Loss) From Continuing Operations for Annual 2016, 2015, 2014, 2009 and 2008 for these Michigan Companies During the Obama Administration.

Year
Obama Obama Before
Obama Second Third Obama Obama
Last Last Last First First
Year Year Year Year Year
2016 2015 2014 2009 2008
Audited Audited Audited Audited Audited
Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax
Michigan Companies City State 2016 Income Income Income Income Income
Stock Market Caps Above $1 Bil HQs HQs FYE (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss)
 $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils
Detroit Area Cos
General Motors Detroit MI Dec 16     12,008       8,371       4,246   (25,104)   (29,285)
Ford Motor Dearborn MI Dec 16       6,796     10,252       1,234       2,599   (14,895)
Ally Financial Detroit MI Dec 16       1,581       1,393       1,246     (6,959)       4,737
Lear Corp Southfield MI Dec 16       1,411       1,081          824        (643)        (579)
DTE Energy Detroit MI Dec 16       1,105          950       1,275          782          819
Aptiv plc Troy MI Dec 16       1,035       1,013       1,635     (1,160)     (1,821)
BorgWarner Auburn Hills MI Dec 16          943          875          980            18            14
Masco Livonia MI Dec 16          830          689          507        (151)        (193)
Autoliv Auburn Hills MI Dec 16          804          676          667              6          249
Credit Acceptance Corp Southfield MI Dec 16          531          475          421          229          107
Penske Automotive Group Bloomfield Hills MI Dec 16          508          492          458          129        (517)
WABCO Holdings Rochester Hills MI Dec 16          369          298          357            13          254
Domino's Pizza Ann Arbor MI Dec 16          345          306          259          136            83
American Axle Detroit MI Dec 16          299          273          177        (297)     (1,121)
Syntel Troy MI Dec 16          273          327          319          135          100
Flagstar Troy MI Dec 16          258          240        (103)        (442)        (423)
Cooper-Standard Holdings Novi MI Dec 16          195          153            88        (395)          (93)
Taubman Centers Bloomfield Hills MI Dec 16          190          195       1,280          (78)            (7)
Visteon Van Buren Township MI Dec 16          161            69          (43)          324        (531)
Meritor Troy MI Sep 16          155            67          315          (68)          115
Chemical Financial Detroit MI Dec 16          150          124            90            12            28
Federal-Mogul Southfield MI Dec 16          145          (81)        (105)          (72)        (446)
Gentherm Northville MI Dec 16          111          129            94              1              6
Ramco-Gershenson Prop Trust Farmington Hills MI Dec 16            61            67            (2)            13            32
Agree Realty Bloomfield Hills MI Dec 16            46            40            19            16            14
Universal Logistics Warren MI Dec 16            39            65            73              8            24
Sun Communities Southfield MI Dec 16            31          170            33            (7)          (28)
TriMas Bloomfield Hills MI Dec 16          (58)          (22)            70            21        (124)
Total all 28 Detroit Area Cos
    30,322     28,687     16,414   (30,934)   (43,481)
Total Pretax Income Improvement in $ mils
….. 2016 vs 2009 (Obama's Last Year vs First Year)
                    61,256
….. 2016 vs 2008 (Obama's Last Year vs Year B4 First Year)
                    73,803
Adient plc Plymouth MI Sep 17          377          944          670  N/A   N/A 
Delphi Technologies plc Troy MI Dec 17          318          398          439  N/A   N/A 
Metaldyne Performance Group Southfield MI Dec 17          135          174            54            18  N/A 
Diplomat Pharmacy Flint MI Dec 17            36            41              9              3  N/A 
Altair Engineering Troy MI Dec 17            14            12  N/A   N/A   N/A 
Veoneer Southfield MI Dec 17          (22)            (8)  N/A   N/A   N/A 
Esperion Therapeutics Ann Arbor MI Dec 17          (75)          (50)          (36)  N/A   N/A 
Total all 35 Detroit Area Cos
    31,105     30,198     17,550   (30,913)   (43,481)
Total Pretax Income % Increase
   
….. 2016 vs 2015 (Obama's Last Year vs Second Last Year)
            
   3%
….. 2015 vs 2014 (Obama's 2nd Last Year vs 3rd Last Year)                                                                                   

 72%
Michigan Cos Outside of Detroit Area
Stryker Kalamazoo MI Dec 16       1,921       1,735       1,160       1,624       1,580
Whirlpool Benton Harbor MI Dec 16       1,114       1,031          881          293          246
Kellogg Battle Creek MI Dec 16          928          773          819       1,684       1,631
CMS Energy Jackson MI Dec 16          826          796          729          335          440
Gentex Zeeland MI Dec 16          511          464          415            96            92
Steelcase Grand Rapids MI Feb 17          196          175          137          (31)            (9)
Herman Miller Zeeland MI May 17          179          197          145            35            99
Universal Forest Products Grand Rapids MI Dec 16          161          131            96            39              7
La-Z-Boy Monroe MI Apr 17          131          125          106            43          (96)
Wolverine World Wide Rockford MI Dec 16          111          165          182            86          141
Neogen Lansing MI May 17            67            56            52            27            22
Total all 46 Michigan Cos
    37,250     35,846     22,272   (26,682)   (39,328)


Total Pretax Income Improvement in $ mils
…2016 vs 2008 (Obama's Last Year vs First Year)
                     63,932
…2016 vs 2009 (Obama's Last Year vs Year B4 First Year)
                      76,578           
Total Pretax Income % Increase
…2016 vs 2015 (Obama's Last Year vs Second Last Year)
4%
…2015 vs 2014 (Obama's 2nd Last Year vs 3rd Last Year)
61%

I excluded both DowDupont and Perrigo because the magnitude of their unusual one-time items was so enormous and thus resulted in their GAAP Reported Pretax Income (Loss) amounts to be not very meaningful.