Monday, February 17, 2020

Largest Minnesota Companies March 2019 Quarter Pretax Income Up 11% But Then Increase By Only 0.4% in the Most Recent Three Quarters 2019 Combined. Assuming Bernie Sanders Can Eliminate Health Insurance Cos, Then Minnesota Largest Companies Without UnitedHealth Group Total Pretax Income Drops From Up 11% in the March 2019 Quarter to Up 7% and Drops From Up 0.4% in the Three Most Recent Quarters 2019 Combined to Down 4.0%. UnitedHealth Group's Profits Tower Over all the Other Minnesota Companies and If Its High-Growth Profits Are Gone, Total Minnesota Companies Profits Drop Precipitously.

There were 13 Minnesota Companies with stock market caps above $10 bil in Late December 2019.  One of these 13 has not released its December 2019 quarter earnings yet.    That leaves 12.

From a review of SEC filings, below are the Gold-Standard US GAAP Pretax Income (Loss) From Continuing Operations for the remaining 12 largest Minnesota Companies in each of the four quarters of both 2019 and 2018.


US US US US US US US US
GAAP GAAP GAAP GAAP GAAP GAAP GAAP GAAP
Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax Pretax
Income Income Income Income Income Income Income Income
(Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss)
Dec Dec Sept Sept June June March March
Minnesota Largest Companies Minnesota Quarter Quarter Quarter Quarter Quarter Quarter Quarter Quarter
Market Caps Above $10 Bil City HQs 2019 2018 2019 2018 2019 2018 2019 2018
mils $ mils $ mils $ mils $ mils $ mils $ mils $ mils $
UnitedHealth Group Minneapolis       4,658       4,123       4,565       4,237       4,326       3,860       4,432       3,724
All Cos But UnitedHealth Group
US Bancorp Minneapolis       1,847       2,153       2,384       2,282       2,277       2,199       2,086       2,044
3M Saint Paul       1,212       1,720       1,966       1,965       1,446       2,350       1,088          965
Medtronic plc Minneapolis       1,294       1,355          977       1,180       1,292       1,725       1,370       1,027
Target Minneapolis          901          713       1,217       1,022       1,021          927       1,014       1,012
Travelers Companies Saint Paul       1,074          746          432          806          665          631          967          778
Ameriprise Financial Minneapolis          534          652          641          588          587          548          470          696
General Mills Minneapolis          722          435          574          489          616          424          542          503
XCEL Energy Minneapolis          299          209          599          564          262          319          340          350
Best Buy Richfield          389          330          307          329          330          257          972          873
Hormel Foods Austin          324          322          261          258          318          297          307          305
Fastenal Winona          236          230          278          259          271          266          258          232
CH Robinson Worldwide Eden Prairie          126          246          188          239          221          214          207          181
Total all 12 Cos But UnitedHealth Group       8,958       9,111       9,824       9,981       9,306     10,157       9,621       8,966
….. % Change From Prior Year Quarter -2% -2% -8% 7%
Total all 13 Minnesota Companies     13,616     13,234     14,389     14,218     13,632     14,017     14,053     12,690
….. % Change From Prior Year Quarter 3% 1% -3% 11%
With UnitedHealth Group
Total Pretax Income Last 3Qs 2019     41,637
Total Pretax Income Last 3Qs 2018     41,469
….. % Change From Prior Year 0.4%
Without UnitedHealth Group
… Total Pretax Income Last 3Qs 2019     28,088
… Total Pretax Income Last 3Qs 2018     29,249
.….. % Change From Prior Year -4.0%

Such modest earnings in the most recent three quarters signal unhealthy future pay raises for the many already underpaid Minnesota non-executive employees.


Minnesota Company non-executive workers really have had the deck stacked against them for decades versus what is going on with the sky-high annual percentage pay and employee benefit raises of their Companies' Top-Tier Executives.

So which 2020 Democratic Presidential candidate could best help close this massive annual percentage pay raise gap between Minnesota Company Top-Tier executives and their already massively underpaid, hardworking Minnesota non-executive employees?

More than anything needed to solve this thorny problem is to possess exceptionally strong financial and data science skills, coupled with a keen understanding of how businesses operate.  And you also must have a high degree of  economic fairness. 

Joe Biden, Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren and Amy Klobuchar all have little if any financial acumen, no data science understanding and little if any understanding of how businesses operate.

Further, all four of them worked for the US Government, particularly in the past ten years, when these comparative pay raise results of Top-Tier Executives and non-executive employees were so horrendous, not just in Minnesota but also in every other US State.  

On the positive side, all four of them have a high degree of economic fairness.

Michael Bloomberg has both the financial acumen and the understanding of how businesses operate.  

But he has no data science expertise. 

Also and most important of all, Bloomberg has a low degree of economic fairness.  In the many years he was accumulating his wealth of $60+ bil, US income inequality expanded dramatically in each year by leaps and bounds.  So, like many US business tycoons with their sole fixation on maximization of Company profits, Bloomberg accumulated his massive wealth on the backs of the declining US middle class and the growing number of people dropped to the lower economic class.  And by his punitively racial "Stop and Frisk" policy, many New York City people of color were physically thrown against the wall.

And while he was accumulating his massive amount of wealth, Bloomberg was against unions.


I think there is only one Democratic Presidential candidate who has the requisite financial acumen, data science skills, understanding of how business operate and economic fairness to help turn the tide around on this massive, continuing US income inequality expansion caused mainly by the massive gap in annual percentage pay raises between executive and non-executive employees  ....Pete Buttigieg.