Tuesday, April 29, 2014

Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospital Bottom Line Profits Up 478% Under Obama and the ACA Through 2012

Just recently, the State of Florida included on its Agency for Health Care Administration website (ahca.myflorida.com) its 2012 Hospital Financial Data.  This very informative information came from financial data filed by Florida Hospitals with the Agency.  I think it would be very helpful to State citizens if other States would follow the State of Florida's outstanding financial transparency lead here.

In this first post on this Florida Hospital Financial Data, I will cover key aspects of the General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals.  There were 72 of them reporting their financial data to the State of Florida in 2012.

What stuck out to me is how the Total Profits of these Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals have dramatically increased during the Obama Administration and the Affordable Care Act (ACA) through 2012.

In 2008, the last year of the Bush 2 Administration, the Total Operating Income of all Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals was $455.6 mil, which was 2.5% of Total Operating Revenues of $18.274 bil.

Then subsequent to 2008, this Total Operating Income Margin consistently and markedly increased each year, going from 2.5% in 2008 to 4.0% in 2009, then to 5.3% in 2010, then to 6.5% in 2011 and then to 6.9% in 2012. 

Thus for the first 4 years of the Obama Administration, this Total Operating Income Margin Percentage increased by a substantial 176% from 2.5% in 2008 to 6.9% in 2012.

In dollar terms, this Operating Income Margin increased even more so during the first 4 years of the Obama Administration or by 229%, going from $455.6 mil in 2008 to $1.499.4 bil in 2012.

The chart below shows the Total Operating Income, Total Operating Revenues and Total Operating Margin Percentages of all Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals for each of the 10 years from 2003 to 2012:
Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals



Operating

Total Total Income

Operating Operating Margin

Income Revenues %

$000s $000s




2003           416,765          12,831,317 3.2%
2004           434,822          13,978,741 3.1%
2005           583,884          15,037,063 3.9%
2006           394,533          15,747,082 2.5%
2007           403,678          17,107,886 2.4%
2008           455,580          18,274,208 2.5%
2009           762,469          19,199,099 4.0%
2010        1,078,367          20,227,076 5.3%
2011        1,354,700          20,789,586 6.5%
2012        1,499,413          21,640,512 6.9%

As great as growth of these above Total Operating Income Margins of all of these Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals were during the first 4 years of the Obama Administration, this was just a drop in the bucket as compared to the spectacular growth in the Bottom Line Profit Margin growth.  Bottom Line Profit includes both Operating Income and Non-Operating Income, the latter being predominately Total Investment Returns.

In 2008, the last year of the Bush 2 Administration, the Total Bottom Line Income of all Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals was $315.0 mil, which was 1.7% of Total Operating Revenues of $18.274 bil.

Then subsequent to 2008, this Total Bottom Line Income Margin consistently and markedly increased each year, going from 1.7% in 2008 to 5.0% in 2009, then to 6.6% in 2010, then to 6.8% in 2011 and then to an amazingly high 8.4% in 2012. 

Thus for the first 4 years of the Obama Administration, this Total Bottom Line Income Margin Percentage increased by a spectacular 394% from 1.7% in 2008 to 8.4% in 2012.

In dollar terms, this Total Bottom Line Income Margin increased even more so during the first 4 years of the Obama Administration or by an even more spectacular 478%, going from $315.0 mil in 2008 to $1.821.3 bil in 2012.

It is very easy for me to understand why so many in the Hospital Industry like both the Obama Administration and the ACA so much.....they have flat out thrived during them.

The chart below shows the Total Bottom Line Income, Total Operating Revenues and Total Bottom Line Income Margin Percentages of all Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals for each of the 5 years from 2008 to 2012:
Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals



Bottom

Total Line

Bottom Total Income

Line Operating Margin

Income Revenues %

$000s $000s




2008           314,986          18,274,208 1.7%
2009           956,548          19,199,099 5.0%
2010        1,325,432          20,227,076 6.6%
2011        1,404,921          20,789,586 6.8%
2012        1,821,327          21,640,512 8.4%

The chart below shows the 2012 above amounts for each of the 72 Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals:




2012




Bottom


2012
Line


Bottom 2012 Profit


Line Total (Loss)


Profit Operating Margin
County Hospital Name (Loss) Revenues %


$000s $000s
Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals


Duval Baptist Medical Center-Jacksonville          189,553               760,455 24.9%
Hillsborough South Florida Baptist Hospital             21,379                 92,976 23.0%
Flagler Florida Hospital Flagler             26,573               117,172 22.7%
Nassau Baptist Medical Center-Nassau             12,029                 56,522 21.3%
Walton Sacred Heart Hospital Emerald Coast             15,438                 85,268 18.1%
Lee Lee Memorial Hospital          100,824               598,127 16.9%
Duval Baptist Medical Center-Beaches             17,347               106,845 16.2%
Broward Cleveland Clinic Hospital             32,817               204,364 16.1%
Pinellas Morton Plant Hospital             62,400               443,755 14.1%
Brevard Holmes Regional Medical Center             59,537               426,250 14.0%
Pinellas St Anthony's Hospital             28,336               210,319 13.5%
Hillsborough St Joseph's Hospital             99,677               763,367 13.1%
Pasco Morton Plant North Bay Hospital             13,358               105,804 12.6%
Pinellas Mease Dunedin Hospital             41,879               336,912 12.4%
Orange Orlando Regional Medical Center          176,931            1,565,291 11.3%
Duval Mayo Clinic             45,635               405,625 11.3%
Polk Lakeland Regional Medical Center             59,688               553,404 10.8%
Duval St Vincent's Medical Center Riverside             42,847               412,092 10.4%
Orange Florida Hospital          241,979            2,381,665 10.2%
Miami-Dade Doctors Hospital             18,868               190,599 9.9%
Hillsborough Florida Hospital Carrollwood             10,481               105,917 9.9%
Lee Cape Coral Hospital             17,701               181,216 9.8%
Lake Florida Hospital Waterman             19,013               197,657 9.6%
St Johns Flagler Hospital             18,990               201,040 9.4%
Leon Tallahassee Memorial Hospital             40,236               450,140 8.9%
Miami-Dade Baptist Hospital Miami             71,924               819,170 8.8%
Volusia Bert Fish Medical Center               5,678                 64,846 8.8%
Brevard Cape Canaveral Hospital               8,607               100,794 8.5%
Escambia Sacred Heart Hospital             32,112               385,761 8.3%
Miami-Dade South Miami Hospital             36,659               443,546 8.3%
Hillsborough Florida Hospital Tampa             29,316               356,657 8.2%
Palm Beach Bethesda Hospital East             20,366               256,573 7.9%
Martin Martin Medical Center             22,570               285,649 7.9%
Lake South Lake Hospital             10,528               133,927 7.9%
Volusia Florida Hospital Deland               9,153               119,000 7.7%
Alachua Shands Hospital University Florida             80,637            1,051,923 7.7%
Lake Leesburg Regional Medical Center             16,764               221,463 7.6%
Broward Holy Cross Hospital             21,144               324,007 6.5%
Brevard Palm Bay Hospital               5,020                 77,731 6.5%
Madison Madison County Memorial Hospital                  543                    8,515 6.4%
Volusia Florida Hospital Fish Memorial               7,061               120,428 5.9%
Miami-Dade Mount Sinai Medical Center             25,459               438,637 5.8%
Collier Naples Community Hospital             23,632               408,910 5.8%
Hillsborough Tampa General Hospital             48,192               932,600 5.2%
Highlands Florida Hospital Heartland Med Ctr               7,292               141,550 5.2%
Polk Winter Haven Hospital             11,890               241,499 4.9%
Escambia Baptist Hospital             16,905               352,326 4.8%
Volusia Florida Hospital Oceanside             10,250               214,260 4.8%
Duval St Vincent's Med Center Southside               7,323               154,466 4.7%
Pasco Florida Hospital Zephyrhills               5,375               129,884 4.1%
Lee Gulf Coast Med Ctr Lee Memorial             10,894               281,454 3.9%
Monroe Mariners Hospital               1,490                 44,996 3.3%
Palm Beach Jupiter Medical Center               3,672               171,344 2.1%
Sumter Villages Regional Hospital               2,341               144,965 1.6%
Hardee Florida Hospital Wauchula                  147                 20,356 0.7%
Indian River Indian River Medical Center                     80               167,755 0.0%
Taylor Doctors Memorial Hospital                 (273)                 18,782 -1.5%
Palm Beach Boca Raton Regional Hospital             (4,599)               307,976 -1.5%
Calhoun Calhoun-Liberty Hospital                  (231)                    9,467 -2.4%
Miami-Dade University Miami Hospital           (11,507)               335,943 -3.4%
Citrus Citrus Memorial Hospital             (6,609)               137,320 -4.8%
Duval UF Health Jacksonville           (25,411)               493,420 -5.1%
Pinellas Bayfront Medical Center           (12,492)               238,891 -5.2%
Orange Health Central             (3,374)                 59,412 -5.7%
Santa Rosa Jay Hospital                 (612)                 10,282 -6.0%
Pinellas Florida Hospital North Pinellas             (6,447)                 68,455 -9.4%
Monroe Fishermen's Hospital             (2,235)                 23,070 -9.7%
Miami-Dade Homestead Hospital           (18,086)               163,829 -11.0%
Brevard Viera Hospital             (8,332)                 61,417 -13.6%
Pasco Florida Hospital Wesley Chapel             (1,904)                 12,954 -14.7%
Miami-Dade West Kendall Baptist Hospital           (37,380)               122,522 -30.5%
Gulf Sacred Heart Hospital on the Gulf             (5,718)                    9,001 -63.5%




Total 72 General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals       1,821,330         21,640,515 8.4%

Clearly, there is a huge range of Bottom Line Profit (Loss) Margin Percentages:
  • 4 of the 72 had 2012 Profit Margins above 20%
  • 19 of the 72 had 2012 Profit Margins above 10%
  • 16 of the 72 had Losses in 2012
Given that so many of these Non-Profit Hospitals have such incredibly robust Profit Margin Percentages, I have to ask this question.....Is Non-Profit Hospitals really the correct name for them?

And frankly, I can't even come close to getting many of the above Bottom Line Profit (Loss) amounts to tie out with their Audited Financial Statements. As a general rule, the Audited Financial Statements located online at EMMA have significantly higher 2012 Bottom Line Profits than what these Hospitals reported to the State of Florida.

But there is much more to this incredible profit story of these Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals.

The 2012 Total Operating Income of $1.499 bil and 2012 Total Bottom Line Income of $1.821 bil both include a monstrous earnings charge for Total Provisions for Bad Debts of $2.191 bil.  In addition, the 2012 Uncompensated Charity Care Charges Foregone were another monstrous $4.450 bil.  With the ACA, a significant portion of these 2 items will be eliminated, thereby markedly increasing the Patient Service Fee Income and thus also the Income of every Florida Hospital.  And if Florida were to fully expand Medicaid, a huge portion of these 2 items will be eliminated, thereby very substantially increasing the Patient Service Fee Income and also the Income of nearly every Florida Hospital.

Yeah, I think it is time for these Florida General Acute Care Non-Profit Hospitals to patriotically step up by removing a good chunk of their excessive profits by reducing their very steep Patient Service Fee Charges and also negotiating more fairly with Health Insurance Companies.  This responsible action will result in substantially reduced health insurance premiums as well as an additional substantial reduction in the annual growth rate of Total US Health Care Costs.