Saturday, August 11, 2012

Wisconsin 48 Largest Corps 2011 Annual Earnings up 316% over 2009 Under Obama: An Update

From an extensive review of SEC filings, I found 19 Corps headquartered in Wisconsin with Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of more than $100 mil in any of the most recent three years.

These 19 Largest Wisconsin Corps had Total Pretax Income of $9.5 bil in the most recent fiscal year 2011, which was an off-the-charts 367% increase over such amount two years earlier in 2009.

And I also found 29 additional Corps headquartered in Wisconsin with Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of at least $10 mil in any of the most recent three years, but with none of the three years having Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of more than $100 mil.

These 29 Smaller Wisconsin Corps had their Total Pretax Income in the most recent fiscal year 2011 precisely double from such amount two years earlier in 2009.

Thus, these 48 Largest Wisconsin Corps, which file with the SEC, had their Total Pretax Income in the most recent fiscal year 2011 increase by an off-the-charts 316% over such amount two years earlier in 2009.

Wisconsin citizens have to be very proud of their superb Wisconsin companies.

And Wisconsin citizens also have to be elated with how the Obama Administration has created such a robust US economic environment which has fostered their companies' exceptional earnings growth in the most recent two years.

But there is another very important story here.

It is just incredible how much better the total earnings growth of these 48 Largest Wisconsin Corps was in 2010 over 2009, when the US House was under Moderate Democratic control, than it was in 2011 over 2010, when the US House was under Very Conservative Republican control, with Vice Presidential Candidate Paul Ryan being one of the key drivers of this Uncompromising, Very Conservative Republican Movement, which has such an extremely low approval rating in the eyes of US citizens.

Just how much better?  Well, the Total Pretax Income growth of these 48 Largest Wisconsin Corps was 17% in 2011 over 2010.  On the other hand, this 17% total earnings growth under Very Conservative Republican control of the US House was dwarfed by the 15 times higher earnings growth of 255% in 2010 over 2009 under Moderate Democratic control of the US House. 

So, the conventional wisdom that businesses perform far better under Republican control than under Democratic control was certainly not true in Wisconsin.....nor was it true in nearly in any other US State.

And this Wisconsin Largest Corp 2011 total earnings growth of 17% was dramatically sliced by more than two-thirds in the first half of 2012, under the Paul Ryan/Eric Canter-led Uncompromising, Very Conservative Republican control of the US House.

Clearly, the best combination for the US economy is a Moderate Democratic President and a Moderate Democratic US House.  This is precisely what we had in 2009 and 2010.

So many pundits criticize the Obama Economic Stimulus.  It started really kicking in starting in the 4Q 2009, when the Obama Administration’s economic stimulus programs, both business income tax incentives and individual income tax cuts, as well as wisely designed, very carefully vetted US Government investments, were all going full throttle.  And look at the result in annual 2010, with Wisconsin's 48 Largest Corps increasing their total earnings by a massive 255% in just one year.

So, why it is that the total earnings growth was so substantially lower in annual 2011 and in the first half of 2012 in Wisconsin and all over the country, when the US House is under Very Conservative Republican control?

Well, this Very Conservative Republican US House has no interest in compromise.  Thus, nearly every wise, much-needed Obama economic initiative was stopped by this US House, and also stopped by filibustering by US Senate Republicans.

And the losers here were not just the unemployed, the underemployed, the dwindling middle class, and the people trying to get into the middle class.  US Businesses were also big losers, by having their earnings growth substantially decelerate in 2011, and even more dramatically so in the first half of 2012.

I think the only way the US economy will be great again is for a combination of a Moderate Democratic President and a US House under control by Moderate Democrats.  And a US Senate under control by Moderate Democrats would also help.  If so, the country will be back to 2010 again, when US business earnings were on fire!

In deriving Ongoing, Core Pretax Income, I start with Pretax Income under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), and then exclude several clearly unusual very large items relative to Pretax Income, such as Asset Impairments, and Gains and Losses on both Debt Retirements and Asset Dispositions.

I use Pretax Income rather than After-tax Net Income, since so much of the change in effective income tax rates just happens due to financial engineering.

I excluded Corps in the Development Stage.  I also excluded Corps with not significant enough Total Revenues. 

Below here is the Ongoing, Core Pretax Income (PTI) and Pretax Loss (PTL) of these 19 Largest and 29 Smaller Wisconsin Corps for each of the most recent three years, along with the related percentage changes.







US House US House Obama





Republican Democratic Bump




Control Control Two





PTI(L) PTI(L) Year





% % %


Total Total Total Change Change Change


PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) 2011 2010 2011


2011 2010 2009 vs vs vs

mils $s mils $s mils $s 2010 2009 2009
Wisconsin Largest Corps






Johnson Controls Milwaukee 2,111 1,763 (207) 20% 952% 1120%
Kohls Menomonee Falls 1,859 1,788 1,558 4% 15% 19%
Joy Global Milwaukee 896 679 683 32% -1% 31%
Rockwell Automation Milwaukee 868 544 274 60% 99% 217%
Fiserv Brookfield 814 793 734 3% 8% 11%
Harley Davidson Milwaukee 793 475 207 67% 129% 283%
Manpower Milwaukee 480 264 38 82% 595% 1163%
Oshkosh Oshkosh 417 1,212 12 -66% 10000% 3375%
Snap-On Kenosha 413 277 205 49% 35% 101%
Bemis Neenah 292 327 240 -11% 36% 22%
Regal Beloit Beloit 226 221 138 2% 60% 64%
Associated Banc-Corp Green Bay 183 (41) (285) 546% 86% 164%
Sensient Technologies Milwaukee 171 154 123 11% 25% 39%
AO Smith Milwaukee 162 109 92 49% 18% 76%
Actuant Menomonee Falls 159 89 58 79% 53% 174%
Brady Milwaukee 144 109 97 32% 12% 48%
Spectrum Brands Madison 49 (121) 15 140% -907% 227%
Anchor Bancorp Wisconsin Madison (37) (41) (178) 10% 77% 79%
MGIC Investment Milwaukee (484) (359) (1,765) -35% 80% 73%








Total all 19 Largest Corps
9,516 8,242 2,039 15% 304% 367%








Wisconsin Smaller Corps






Generac Holdings Waukesha 96 62 28 55% 121% 243%
Plexus Corp Neenah 92 90 51 2% 76% 80%
Briggs & Stratton Wauwatosa 81 80 40 1% 100% 103%
Roundy's Supermarkets Milwaukee 78 79 88 -1% -10% -11%
National Presto Industries Eau Claire 75 99 94 -24% 5% -20%
Manitowoc Manitowoc 67 0 (4) NM 100% 1775%
Quad/Graphics Sussex 63 43 48 47% -10% 31%
Rexnord Milwaukee 58 40 (49) 45% 182% 218%
Modine Manufacturing Racine 48 13 (13) 269% 200% 469%
Twin Disc Racine 48 32 2 50% 1500% 2300%
Marten Transport Mondovi 43 35 29 23% 21% 48%
Roadrunner Transportation Cudahy 42 22 0 91% NM NM
Journal Communications Milwaukee 36 50 27 -28% 85% 33%
Assisted Living Concepts Menomonee Falls 36 28 24 29% 17% 50%
Marcus Milwaukee 36 21 28 71% -25% 29%
Douglas Dynamics Milwaukee 31 11 14 182% -21% 121%
Badger Meter Milwaukee 27 44 42 -39% 5% -36%
Weyco Group Glendale 25 21 20 19% 5% 25%
Tri City Bankshares Oak Creek 14 23 15 -39% 53% -7%
First Business Financial Services Madison 12 6 2 100% 200% 500%
Johnson Outdoors Racine 12 9 (10) 33% 190% 220%
Strattec Security Milwaukee 10 6 (11) 67% 155% 191%
Bank Mutual Brown Deer 7 (33) 19 121% -274% -63%
Wausau Paper Mosinee 3 28 30 -89% -7% -90%
CIB Marine Bancshares Waukesha (6) (17) (41) 65% 59% 85%
Waterstone Financial Wauwatosa (7) (2) (11) -250% 82% 36%
School Specialty Greenville (18) (8) 44 -125% -118% -141%
Appleton Papers Appleton (22) (37) (19) 41% -95% -16%
Great Wolf Resorts Madison (23) (36) (5) 36% -620% -360%








Total all 29 Smaller Corps
964 709 482 36% 47% 100%








Grand Total all 48 Corps
10,480 8,951 2,521 17% 255% 316%