Friday, August 17, 2012

Minnesota 48 Smaller Corps 2011 Annual Earnings Up 180% Over 2009 Under Obama: An Update

I found 35 Minnesota headquartered Corps, which file with the SEC, and which generated Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of $100 mil or more in any of the most recent three years.

I also found 48 Minnesota headquartered Smaller Corps, which file with the SEC, which had Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of $10 mil or more in any of the most recent three years, and which weren't included in the 35 Largest Minnesota Corps.  Thus, these 48 Smaller Minnesota Corps also did not have Pretax Income or Pretax Loss of $100 mil or more in any of the most recent three years.

These 48 Smaller Minnesota Corps generated total earnings growth in the most recent two years of a very impressive 180%.

Clearly, Minnesota citizens should be very proud of their many superb Minnesota Smaller companies. 

And yeah, the Obama Administration created a very robust US economic environment, which permitted the overwhelming majority of these Minnesota Smaller Companies to do extremely well on the earnings front in the most recent two years.

These 48 Smaller Minnesota Corps had substantially better earnings growth in 2010 over 2009 (+108%), when the US House was under Democratic Control, than in 2011 over 2010 (+35%), when the US House was under Republican Control. 

In deriving Pretax Income, I start with Pretax Income under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), and then exclude several clearly unusual very large items relative to Pretax Income, such as Asset Impairments, and Gains and Losses on both Debt Retirements and Asset Dispositions.

I use Pretax Income rather than After-tax Net Income, since so much of the change in effective income tax rates just happens due to financial engineering.

I excluded Corps in the Development Stage, and ones without significant enough Total Revenues.

Below here is the Ongoing, Core Pretax Income (PTI) and Pretax Loss (PTL) of these 48 Smaller Minnesota Corps for each of the most recent three years, along with the related percentage changes. 









Obama





US House US House Bump





Republican Democratic Two





Control Control Year





PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L)





% % %


Change Change Change


PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) 2011 2010 2011


2011 2010 2009 vs vs vs


mils $s mils $s mils $s 2010 2009 2009
Minnesota Smaller Corps HQs





Select Comfort Minneapolis 90 50 18 80% 178% 400%
Capella Education Minneapolis 82 97 66 -15% 47% 24%
Northern Oil & Gas Wayzata 77 26 5 196% 420% 1440%
Buffalo Wild Wings Minneapolis 73 57 45 28% 27% 62%
MTS Systems Eden Prairie 73 27 24 170% 13% 204%
G&K Services Minnetonka 60 65 60 -8% 8% 0%
Nash Finch South Minneapolis 58 72 66 -19% 9% -12%
Tennant Co Minneapolis 49 35 19 40% 84% 158%
Arctic Cat Plymouth 46 18 1 156% 1700% 4500%
Moneygram Intl Minneapolis 45 56 (30) -20% 287% 250%
Hawkins Inc Minneapolis 35 32 39 9% -18% -10%
The Tile Shop Plymouth 32 30 24 7% 25% 33%
Stratasys Eden Prairie 31 19 6 63% 217% 417%
Piper Jaffray Minneapolis 30 57 57 -47% 0% -47%
Digital River Minnetonka 27 15 67 80% -78% -60%
Proto Labs Maple Plain 27 16 7 69% 129% 286%
Winmark Corp Minneapolis 24 18 10 33% 80% 140%
Thrivent Life Insurance Minneapolis 24 25 21 -4% 19% 14%
Great Northern Iron Ore Properties St Paul 23 17 11 35% 55% 109%
Lakes Entertainment Minnetonka 20 6 7 233% -14% 186%
Communications Systems Minnetonka 19 16 11 19% 45% 73%
NVE Corp Eden Prairie 17 20 18 -15% 11% -6%
Datalink Chanhassen 17 4 0 325% NM NM
Digi International Minnetonka 17 11 4 55% 175% 325%
Vascular Solutions Minneapolis 16 10 8 60% 25% 100%
Caribou Coffee Brooklyn Center 15 10 5 50% 100% 200%
Hickory Tech Mankato 15 16 12 -6% 33% 25%
Granite Falls Energy Granite Falls 12 8 1 50% 700% 1100%
Multiband New Hope 12 10 (11) 20% 191% 209%
TwinCities Power, LLC Lakeville 12 7 (3) 71% 333% 500%
FSI International Chaska 8 13 (18) -38% 172% 144%
Surmodics Eden Prairie 7 6 63 17% -90% -89%
Advanced BioEnergy Minneapolis 6 16 (23) -63% 170% 126%
Cyberoptics Minneapolis 6 4 (11) 50% 136% 155%
Rimage Edina 5 12 13 -58% -8% -62%
Apogee Enterprises Minneapolis 4 (21) 46 119% -146% -91%
Analysts International Minneapolis 3 0 (14) NM 100% 121%
Heron Lake BioEnergy Heron Lake 1 (1) (11) 200% 91% 109%
Granite City Food & Brewery Minneapolis (5) (5) (10) 0% 50% 50%
Wireless Ronin Technologies Minnetonka (7) (8) (10) 13% 20% 30%
Navarre New Hope (8) 4 10 -300% -60% -180%
HMN Financial Rochester (12) (23) (16) 48% -44% 25%
Cardiovascular Systems St Paul (17) (11) (24) -55% 54% 29%
Valuevision Media Eden Prairie (22) (26) (46) 15% 43% 52%
Universal Hospital Services Edina (30) (27) (30) -11% 10% 0%
Imation Oakdale (36) (21) (28) -71% 25% -29%
Dolan Co. Minneapolis (51) (56) (57) 9% 2% 11%
Hutchinson Technology Hutchinson (56) (57) (90) 2% 37% 38%








Total all 48 Smaller Corps
874 649 312 35% 108% 180%

Minnesota is also blessed with many outstanding larger Corps.

To show how impressive Minnesota Largest Corps as a group are, in 2009, when the country was still suffering severely from the aftershocks of the financial meltdown, these 35 Largest Minnesota Corps very resiliently generated Total Pretax Income of $40.6 bil, which was up 5% from 2008.  This incredible performance occurred when the US House was under Democratic control.

Then in 2010, these 35 Largest Minnesota Corps generated total earnings growth of 18%, when the US House was still under Democratic control. 

Then in 2011, when the US House turned to Republican control, the total earnings growth of these 35 Largest Minnesota Corps decelerated to only 3%.


Minnesota citizens should be very proud of their many superb Largest Minnesota companies.  They hang in there very tough during severe economic downturns.

Below here are these 35 Largest Minnesota Corps, and where they are headquartered.


Minnesota Largest Corps
UnitedHealth Group Minneapolis
US Bancorp Minneapolis
3M St Paul
Target Minneapolis
Medtronic Minneapolis
Mosaic Plymouth
Best Buy Richfield
General Mills Minneapolis
Ameriprise Financial Minneapolis
Travelers St Paul
St Jude Medical St Paul
CHS Inver Grove Heights
American Crystal Sugar Moorhead
Hormel Foods Austin
CH Robinson Eden Prairie
Ecolab St Paul
Fastenal Winona
Enbridge Energy Partners Duluth
Alliant Techsystems Minneapolis
Supervalu Eden Prairie
Polaris Industries Medina
Patterson Companies St Paul
Pentair Golden Valley
Donaldson Co Minneapolis
Valspar Minneapolis
Deluxe Shoreview
Graco Minneapolis
TCF Financial Wayzata
Toro Bloomington
Techne Minneapolis
Life Time Fitness Chanhassen
Two Harbors Investment Minnetonka
HB Fuller St Paul
Fair Isaac Minneapolis
Regis Corp Minneapolis


And below here is the Ongoing, Core Pretax Income (PTI) and Pretax Loss (PTL) of these 35 Largest Minnesota Corps for each of the most recent four years, along with the related percentage changes. 










Obama




US House US House US House Bump




Republican Democratic Democratic Three





Control Control Control Year 





PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L)





% % % %


Change Change Change Change

PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) PTI(L) 2011 2010 2009 2011

2011 2010 2009 2008 vs vs vs vs

mils $s mils $s mils $s mils $s 2010 2009 2008 2008
Minnesota Largest Corps






UnitedHealth Group 7,959 7,555 5,808 4,624 5% 30% 26% 72%
US Bancorp 6,629 4,200 2,632 4,099 58% 60% -36% 62%
3M 6,031 5,755 4,632 5,108 5% 24% -9% 18%
Target 4,530 4,495 3,872 3,536 1% 16% 10% 28%
Medtronic 4,235 3,909 4,318 3,875 8% -9% 11% 9%
Mosaic 2,629 2,585 1,190 2,233 2% 117% -47% 18%
Best Buy 2,250 2,331 2,329 1,766 -3% 0% 32% 27%
General Mills 2,211 2,428 2,205 1,857 -9% 10% 19% 19%
Ameriprise Financial 1,385 1,634 920 (423) -15% 78% 317% -427%
Travelers 1,352 4,306 4,711 3,716 -69% -9% 27% -64%
St Jude Medical 1,269 1,266 1,171 1,015 0% 8% 15% 25%
CHS 1,021 554 560 504 84% -1% 11% 103%
American Crystal Sugar 813 535 544 548 52% -2% -1% 48%
Hormel Foods 719 625 528 461 15% 18% 15% 56%
CH Robinson 695 624 587 578 11% 6% 2% 20%
Ecolab 680 748 620 651 -9% 21% -5% 4%
Fastenal 575 431 297 451 33% 45% -34% 27%
Enbridge Energy Partners 507 471 401 402 8% 17% 0% 26%
Alliant Techsystems 407 439 473 407 -7% -7% 16% 0%
Supervalu 404 347 632 745 16% -45% -15% -46%
Polaris Industries 347 219 160 177 58% 37% -10% 96%
Patterson Companies 330 356 339 320 -7% 5% 6% 3%
Pentair 313 300 173 173 4% 73% 0% 81%
Donaldson Co 312 230 161 236 36% 43% -32% 32%
Valspar 307 319 238 229 -4% 34% 4% 34%
Deluxe 223 236 170 170 -6% 39% 0% 31%
Graco 210 149 69 179 41% 116% -61% 17%
TCF Financial 179 244 144 206 -27% 69% -30% -13%
Toro 175 141 96 181 24% 47% -47% -3%
Techne 165 165 156 155 0% 6% 1% 6%
Life Time Fitness 154 134 120 119 15% 12% 1% 29%
Two Harbors Investment 126 35 2 3 260% 1650% -33% 4100%
HB Fuller 122 99 97 98 23% 2% -1% 24%
Fair Isaac 97 92 101 113 5% -9% -11% -14%
Regis Corp 48 53 127 137 -9% -58% -7% -65%









Total all 35 Largest Corps 49,409 48,010 40,583 38,649 3% 18% 5% 28%