Friday, February 15, 2019

The South Bend/Elkhart, Indiana Area Economic Miracle During South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg's Time in Office

......................................................................
The 5 South Bend/Elkhart Area Cos With Stock Market Caps Above $1 Bil Saw Their Total Audited Annual Net Income Increase By 338% So Far During Pete Buttigieg's Run as South Bend Mayor 
......................................................................
On the Other Hand, the 22 Other Indiana Cos With Stock Market Caps Above $1 Bil Saw Their Total Audited Annual Net Income Increase By a Meager 4% So Far During Pete Buttigieg's Run as South Bend Mayor 
......................................................................
These 5 South Bend/Elkhart Area Companies Experienced Double-Digit Total Audited Annual Net Income Growth in Every Year That Pete Buttigieg Has Been South Bend Mayor.  This Total Audited Annual Net Income Growth Ranged From 16% to 37% Per Year, With an Average of 28% Per Year ..... That's What I Call Exceptional Consistency
......................................................................
To Illustrate How Unemployment Rates Are Generally Tied to Company Profits, From the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, the South Bend Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) Had an Unemployment Rate of 9.7% in December 2011, the Month Before Buttigieg Became South Bend Mayor.  In December 2018, this Unemployment Rate Had Dropped Precipitously Down to 3.9%.  And the Neighboring Elkhart Did Even Better.  The Elkhart MSA Had an Unemployment Rate of 10.1% in December 2011.  In December 2018, this Elkhart MSA Registered an Unemployment Rate of Only 2.9%. 
......................................................................

From a review of company SEC filings and of MSN Money individual company common stock information, I found 27 Indiana Companies with stock market caps of more than $1 Bil.

Of these 27 Indiana Cos, 5 of them are located in the South Bend/Elkhart Area.

The chart below shows the Audited Annual Net Income From Continuing Operations for each of these 27 Indiana Companies for every year from 2011, the year before Buttigieg started serving as South Bend Mayor,  to 2017.

 Year 
 Before 
 Buttigieg 
 Was 
 South Bend 
 Mayor 
2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011
Audited Audited Audited Audited Audited Audited Audited
After-Tax After-Tax After-Tax After-Tax After-Tax After-Tax After-Tax
Net Net Net Net Net Net Net
Indiana Companies Income Income Income Income Income Income Income
Reporting Their Financial Statements (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss) (Loss)
To SEC In All Years  (2012 to 2017) From From From From From From From
Pete Buttigieg Was South Bend Mayor 2017 Continuing Continuing Continuing Continuing Continuing Continuing Continuing
Stock Market Caps Above $1 Bil FYE Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations Operations
 $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils  $ mils
South Bend/Elkhart Area Cos
Thor Industries Inc Elkhart IN Jul 17            374            258            202            176            152            111              92
LCI Industries Elkhart IN Dec 17            133            130              74              62              50              37              30
Patrick Industries Inc  Elkhart  IN Dec 17              86              56              42              31              24              28                8
1st Source Corp South Bend IN Dec 17              68              58              57              58              55              50              48
Skyline Corp Elkhart IN May 17                0                2               (4)               (7)             (11)             (19)             (27)
Total all 5 South Bend/Elkhart Area Cos            661            504            371            320            270            207            151
….. Net Income % Increase Over Prior Year 31% 36% 16% 19% 30% 37%
….. Net Income % Increase: 2017 vs 2011 338%
Rest of Indiana Cos
Anthem Indianapolis IN Dec 17         3,843         2,470         2,560         2,560         2,634         2,651         2,647
Simon Property Group Indianapolis IN Dec 17         2,245         2,135         2,139         1,622         1,552         1,720         1,246
Zimmer Biomet Holdings Warsaw IN Dec 17         1,813            305            146            719            759            753            760
Cummins Columbus IN Dec 17            994         1,456         1,470         1,736         1,588         1,738         1,946
Steel Dynamics Fort Wayne IN Dec 17            806            360           (145)              92            164            142            266
Allison Transmission Holdings Indianapolis IN Dec 17            504            215            182            229            165            514            103
KAR Auction Services Carmel IN Dec 17            362            222            215            169              68              92              72
Berry Plastics Group Evansville IN Sep 17            340            236              86              63              57                2           (299)
Duke Realty Corp Indianapolis IN Dec 17            291            298            188            221              62             (86)               (3)
Allegion PLC Carmel IN Dec 17            277            231            155            184              44            228            232
Vectren Evansville IN Dec 17            216            212            197            167            137            159            142
OneMain Holdings Evansville IN Dec 17            183            243             (93)            589              94           (218)           (242)
CNO Financial Group Carmel IN Dec 17            176            358            271              51            478            221            336
NiSource Merrillville IN Dec 17            129            328            199            256            221            171            109
Hillenbrand Inc Batesville IN Sep 17            128            117            113            111              65            105            106
First Merchants Corp Muncie IN Dec 17              96              81              65              60              45              45              25
Old National Bancorp Evansville IN Dec 17              96            134            117            104            101              92              72
Franklin Electric Co Fort Wayne IN Dec 17              79              79              74              71              83              84              64
Lakeland Financial Corp Warsaw IN Dec 17              57              52              46              44              39              35              31
Kite Realty Trust Indianapolis IN Dec 17              14                3              29               (8)               (1)             (11)                4
Endocyte Lafayette IN Dec 17             (55)             (44)             (41)                5             (18)             (17)             (41)
Eli Lilly Indianapolis IN Dec 17           (204)         2,738         2,408         2,391         4,685         4,089         4,348
Total all 22 Rest of Indiana Cos       12,390       12,229       10,381       11,436       13,022       12,509       11,924
….. Net Income % Change vs Prior Year 1% 18% -9% -12% 4% 5%
….. Net Income % Increase: 2017 vs 2011 4%