Saturday, April 18, 2020

The 16 Publicly-Held (Small Business?) Companies Receiving the Largest Forgivable PPP Loans Guaranteed By the SBA Had an Average Number of Employees of 3,495, an Average Annual Revenues of $322 Mil, an Average Annual Pretax Loss of $(20) Mil and an Average Annual CEO Total Compensation of $2.333 Mil. If I Worked On This Approval Process For Either the Bank or For the SBA, I Would Have Approved the PPP Loans of Only Two of These 16 Companies As Truly US Small Businesses.

From a review of bloomberg.com, coupled with a review of Company 8k SEC filings, so far there were 16 publicly-held Companies which received the cherished Forgivable Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loans under the CARES Act of more than $5 mil.

Of these 16, only 3 of them had fewer than 500 employees which has always been the qualification of a small business by the SBA.

Of these 3 Companies, one of them is headquartered in Singapore.  Thus that leaves only two of them that are truly US small businesses ...... SIFCO Industries and Perma-Fix Environmental Services.

Truly US small businesses whose loans were previously rejected by the Bank or by the SBA or not even had their loan application considered would certainly like to get a second chance at this $154 mil of loans that were made to clearly not US small businesses.

But this $154 mil is just a drop in the bucket of all Companies whose loans were approved by the SBA even though they are not truly small businesses.

First, there's the other PPP loans under $5 mil made to publicly-held Companies.

But second and much more importantly, the amount of the PPP loans made to publicly-held companies is minuscule as compared to the amount of PPP loans made to private Companies.

In all fairness, the US Government should provide to the public a list of all private companies receiving PPP loans, the PPP loan amount received and the number of employees of each private company receiving PPP loans ...... with all of this information supplied on a consolidated or combined Company basis rather than on a location basis.

The US Government should also supply a list of foreign-headquartered Companies receiving PPP Loans and the amounts of their PPP Loans.

After reviewing the individual company SBA list by City and US State (but without Company names) of approved PPP Loans and the incredibly high number of various "services" , "financial", "education" and so many other questionable industry-type companies included, there is no question that in these desperate times where so many previous middle-class people are now getting food to feed their family from Food Banks , many unethical people were successfully gaming the system and the Banks and the SBA both facilitated this deceptive, unpatriotic process.  Thus in all fairness, the US Government should supply a list of all of these companies in these questionable industries and the amount of their PPP Loans received and also single out the ones where their business location was one of their home residences.

From Company SEC filings, below is a table summarizing key information related to these 16 publicly-held Companies receiving PPP loans of above $5 mil.

Most
Most Recent Most
Most Recent Year End Recent
Publicly-Held Company Recent FYE Total FYE
Receiving CARES ACT Amount of Stock FYE Pretax Stkhldrs Disclosed
Paycheck Protection Program Forgivable City State # of Market  Total Income Equity CEO
Forgivable SBA Loan SBA Loan Business HQS HQs Employees Cap Revenues (Loss) (Deficit) Pay
000's of $s mils of $s mils of $s mils of $s mils of $s 000's of $s
Forgivable Loans Above $5 Mil
Meritage Hospitality Group        29,100 Restaurants: 331 Wendy's and Also Other Concepts Grand Rapids MI        11,000               74       467.5          16.5               83           1,874
Ruth's Hospitality Group        20,000 Restaurants: 159 Ruth's Chris Steak Houses Winter Park FL           5,740            217       468.0          50.4               94           6,106
J. Alexander Holdings        15,100 Restaurants: 47 Huge, Upscale Dining Locations in 16 US States  Nashville TN           4,200               60       247.3             8.5            131           1,461
Fiesta Restaurant Group        10,000 Restaurants: Fast-Casual 142 Pollo Tropical locations in Florida and 164 Taco Cabana locations in Texas Dallas TX        10,480            169       660.9        (75.0)            158           1,298
Potbelly Corp        10,000 Restaurants: 474 Sandwich Shops Chicago IL           6,000               79       409.7           (9.4)               69           1,668
Shake Shack Inc        10,000 Restaurants: 275 Modern Day Roadside Burger Stands New York NY           7,603       1,610       594.5          27.5            322           3,805
Quantum Group        10,000 Tech: Computer Storage Devices San Jose CA               800            157       402.7        (40.4)          (200)           2,253
ZAGG Inc           9,444 Retail: Miscellaneous Midvale UT               628            101       521.9             5.9            191           2,225
Air T Inc           8,215 Air Courier Services Denver NC               769               33       249.8             4.7               23                  50
WaVe Life Sciences Ltd           7,235 Pharmaceuticals Preparations Singapore               301            266          16.0     (193.6)               64           5,840
New Age Beverages           6,868 Healthy Beverages Denver CO               934            127       253.7        (77.2)               92               363
Lindblad Expeditions Holdings           6,600 Expedition Cruising and Adventure Travel  New York NY               650            236       343.1          20.9            123           1,658
Kura Sushi USA Inc           5,983 Restaurants: Japanese 23 Locations With 81% ownership by a Japanese Parent Corp Irvine CA           1,400               84          64.2             1.5               62               259
Perma-Fix Environmental Services           5,666 Hazardous Waste Management Atlanta GA               325               70          73.5             2.9               29               305
Drive Shack Inc           5,277 Golf-Related Leisure and Entertainment New York NY           4,650               72       272.1        (54.2)               66           7,383
SIFCO Industries           5,025 Aerospace and Energy Parts Manufacturer Cleveland OH               434               14       112.5           (8.2)               36               787
    164,513 Total all 16 Companies        55,914       3,369       5,157          (319)       1,343        37,335
Average of all 16 Companies           3,495            211            322        (20)               84           2,333