Thursday, September 8, 2011

Big Corp Tax Loophole Closer #52: Minimum Tax on All US Big Corp Worldwide Profits

Since I have recently made posts on US Federal Income Taxes Paid, and Effective US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid (ETR), in 2010 by US Big Corps in each of the Sectors, in this post I will summarize the overall results.

The below summary shows US Big Corps with a 2010 ETR below 10% and also ones with a 2010 ETR below 15%. The summary also shows an estimate of positive ten-year CBO scoring to the US Government if a minimum tax of at least 10%, and also one of at least 15%, of worldwide pretax income on these Big US Corps were enacted.

................................US Big Corps with 2010 ETR Below........
......................................10%..............................15%...........
..............................................10 Year........................10 Year
............................................CBO Scoring..................CBO Scoring
..........................# of.....Total......10%.......# of....Total.....15%
...........................Big....2010..Minimum....Big....2010.Minimum
..........................Corps...ETR......Tax........Corps..ETR.......Tax
...............................................bils of $s.......................bils of $s

Big Oil...................35.....3.3%....273.5.......39.....3.6%.....480.5
Big Financial.........23...(6.2)%....259.4.......27....(2.0)%...345.0
Big Conglomerates..6..(11.1)%....131.3.........7....(7.0)%...163.0
Big Health Care.......5....(6.9)%.....95.2........10.....3.2%.....142.1
Big Utility.............30...(7.1)%.....82.6........32....(4.8)%....108.7
Big High Tech........14.....1.5%......73.0........21.....2.3%.....158.7
Big Telecom............6...(0.5)%.....72.9.........8.....0.7%.....110.2
Big Other Sectors..56.....2.4%....155.9........67.....5.2%.....282.7

Total all Sectors..175..(0.7)%..1,143.8.....211.....1.9%..1,790.9

Yeah, that's correct, the 175 most profitable US Big Corps, which paid effective US Federal Income Taxes of less than 10% in 2010, generated $565.7 bil of Consolidated Pretax Profits in 2010.....and how much Total US Federal Income Tax did these 175 US huge US Corps pay in 2010?

Well, in total not a dime, but rather they got Total Net US Federal Income Tax Refunds of $4.0 Bil.....thus a Total US Federal Income Tax Rate Refund of 0.7%.....I'm not kidding.

And how many times have you heard Republicans in the US Senate, and frankly even all of the Republican US Presidential candidates, talk about how US Corporations are paying way too much in US Corporate Federal Income Taxes, and that this is the main reason the US economy is so horrible and US unemployment is so high?

How can you possibly solve a problem when you have no clue what's going on? Instead of thinking independently and acting in the best interests of the country, these US Senate Republicans are just simply parroting what their Big Corp lobbyists are telling them to say.

The SEC is great in football, but the US Senate Republican Leadership from SEC States have little, if any, understanding on the US economy.

It's high time for the US Republicans in both the US Senate and in the US House to reverse course and step up, take the patriotic high road, and work with the Obama Administration in helping the country get out of its horrible economic mess. They have stopped nearly every good economic initiative that the Obama Administration has proposed.

Below here are the 175 US Big Corps with a 2010 Effective US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid below 10% each:

................................Current US..........................Effective
...............................Fed Inc Tax..Consolidated...Tax Rate
..............................Paid(Benefit).........PTI.......Paid(Refund)
...................................2010...............2010...........2010
.......................................(million of $s).....

Big Oil & Gas
Nabors Industries.......(138).................343..........(40.2)%
Weatherford Intl...........(34).................205..........(16.6)%
Halliburton.............(400)............2,655..........(15.1)%
Valero Energy...............(75)..............1,498...........(5.0)%
QEP Resources..............(17).................453...........(3.8)%
El Paso Corp....................(4)..............1,310...........(0.3)%
Newfield Exploration.......(1).................829...........(0.1)%
Chesapeake Energy...........0...............2,884.............0.0%
Pioneer Natural Res..........0.................788.............0.0%
EXCO Resources...............1..................674.............0.1%
Pride Intl..........................1..................252.............0.4%
Apache...........................25...............5,206.............0.5%
Southern Union................2..................350.............0.6%
Southwestern Energy......10..................995.............1.0%
Schlumberger.................76...............5,156.............1.5%
EOG Resources................17................1,151.............1.5%
Ensco Intl.......................10..................645.............1.6%
Exxon Mobil..........1,270............52,959.............2.4%
Noble Energy..................25...............1,031.............2.4%
Ultra Petroleum.............22..................723.............3.0%
Denbury Resources........16..................479.............3.3%
Marathon Oil................183................5,122.............3.6%
FMC Technologies..........21..................538.............3.9%
Hess.............................151................3,311.............4.6%
Chevron.................1,501............32,055.............4.7%
Cimarex Energy.............43..................914.............4.7%
Rowan Companies..........25..................379.............6.6%
ConocoPhillips......1,312............19,750.............6.6%
Devon Energy..............244...............3,568.............6.8%
Helmerich&Payne..........31..................438.............7.1%
Murphy Oil...................105...............1,414.............7.4%
OneOK...........................59..................755.............7.8%
Occidental Petroleum..614...............7,359.............8.3%
Noble Corp....................81..................917.............8.8%
Spectra Energy............105...............1,123.............9.3%
Total 35 Big Oil..........5,281..........158,229.............3.3%

Big Financial Corps
GE Capital Svcs...(3,991).............2,172........(183.7)%
State Street............(885).............2,086..........(42.4)%
Reinsurance Group....(218).................864...........(25.2)%
Lincoln National........(244)..............1,234...........(19.8)%
Bank NY Mellon....(670)............3,694...........(18.1)%
Prudential Fincl...(722).............4,422...........(16.3)%
Ameriprise Financial..(224).............1,594...........(14.1)%
Marsh&McLennan.......(90)................769...........(11.7)%
Bank of America...(666)...........11,077...........(6.0)%
PNC Financial...........(207)..............4,061............(5.1)%
Capital One Financial.(152)..............4,330............(3.5)%
Toyota Motor Credit...(26)..............3,003............(0.9)%
AON.............................16................1,059..............1.5%
NYSE Euronext............18...................686..............2.6%
Morgan Stanley..........213................6,202..............3.4%
MetLife.......................141................3,958..............3.6%
Invesco Ltd.................45...................834..............5.4%
Interactive Brokers......21...................341..............6.2%
Wells Fargo.........1,425..............19,001..............7.5%
Principal Financial......74...................841..............8.8%
American Express......532...............5,964..............8.9%
Western Union...........104................1,145..............9.1%
AFLAC.......................349................3,585..............9.7%
Total 23 Big Fincl...(5,157)............82,922............(6.2)%

Big Conglomerates
GE........................(3,253)...........14,208.........(22.9)%
Honeywell............(471)..............2,843..........(16.6)%
United Technolgy.122...............6,538...............1.9%
Tyco Intl....................45................1,270...............3.5%
Loews.......................154................2,902...............5.3%
Johnson Controls......112................1,763...............6.4%
Total 6 Big Cnglms.(3,291)............29,524............(11.1)%

Big Health Care
Pfizer..................(2,774)............9,422.........(29.4)%
Boston Scientific.......(83).................754...........(11.0)%
Merck....................399.............10,660............3.7%
Baxter.......................73................1,890..............3.9%
Eli Lilly....................376...............6,525..............5.8%
Total 5 BigHealth.(2,009)............29,251...........(6.9)%

Big Utilities
PacifiCorp..............(498)................777...........(64.1)%
MidAmerican Engy.(822).............1,465...........(56.1)%
Edison Intl.............(432)..............1,657...........(26.1)%
PinnacleWestCaptl.(109)................515...........(21.2)%
DTE Energy............(172)................950...........(18.1)%
NiSource.................(62)................436...........(14.2)%
Consolidated Ed.....(144)..............1,399...........(10.3)%
SCANA....................(47)................534............(8.8)%
AEP.......................(134)..............1,849............(7.2)%
EQT.........................(25)................355............(7.0)%
ConstellationEngy...(47)................702............(6.7)%
PublicSrvcEntrpr...(166).............2,616............(6.3)%
PPL.........................(51)..............1,239.............(4.1)%
CMS Energy.............(21)................590.............(3.6)%
Progress Energy......(46)..............1,406.............(3.3)%
FirstEnergy.............(23)..............1,242.............(1.9)%
PG&E.......................(12)..............1,660............(0.7)%
Duke Energy.............(5)..............2,210.............(0.2)%
Nextera Energy.........11..............2,489...............0.4%
Alliant Energy............3.................453...............0.7%
Allegheny Energy......7.................628...............1.1%
Southern Co.............42..............3,066...............1.4%
Xcel Energy.............17...............1,189...............1.4%
TECO Energy.............6.................410...............1.5%
Northeast Utilities....9.................605...............1.5%
Ameren...................13.................476...............2.7%
Sempra Energy........27................786...............3.4%
OGE Energy.............16.................461...............3.5%
CenterPoint Engy....40................705...............5.7%
Entergy.................145..............1,888...............7.7%
Total 30BigUtil.(2,480)...........34,758............(7.1)%

Big High Tech
Garmin Ltd............(46)................577............(8.0)%
Ebay....................(131).............2,098............(6.2)%
Seagate Technlgy....(6)................579............(1.0)%
Juniper Networks...(8)................778............(1.0)%
Corning....................0..............3,845..............0.0%
Priceline..................5.................746..............0.7%
IBM....................190............19,723.............1.0%
Computer Sci.........19.................968..............2.0%
Symantec..............17..................729..............2.3%
Yahoo...................26...............1,070..............2.4%
Western Digital......21..................780..............2.7%
Altera...................30..................868..............3.5%
HP......................484............10,974.............4.4%
CA Technologies..110...............1,209..............9.1%
Total 14BigTech.1,312............88,679..............1.5%

Big Telecom
Verizon..........(705)...........12,684...........(5.6)%
Qwest Comm........(14)................925.............(1.5)%
NII Holdings...........0.................598..............0.0%
AT&T...............307............18,238.............1.7%
TimeWarnerCbl..127...............2,196..............5.8%
CBS......................89...............1,222.............7.3%
Total6BigTelcom.(196).........35,863...........(0.5)%

Big Other Sectors
Intl Paper...........(249)..............822............(30.3)%
Nucor...................(66)..............267............(24.7)%
Dow Chemical.(576)........2,802............(20.6)%
Whirlpool........(101).............586............(17.2)%
Fortune Brands....(61)..............588............(10.4)%
DuPont...............(109)...........3,711.............(2.9)%
Avon Products.....(21)..............945.............(2.2)%
AES.......................(8)............2,265.............(0.4)%
Eaton....................(2)............1,036.............(0.2)%
Carnival.................0.............1,979..............0.0%
Royal Caribbean.....0...............548..............0.0%
Crown Holdings......0...............614..............0.0%
Boeing..................13............4,507..............0.3%
Supervalu..............2...............347..............0.6%
Cummins...............11............1,617..............0.7%
MolsonCoors Brw...8...............809..............1.0%
Coca Cola Enter......8...............746..............1.1%
Bunge, Ltd............33............3,050..............1.1%
PhillipMorris..157..........10,324..............1.5%
CHS.......................9................584..............1.5%
Southern Copper.40.............2,431..............1.6%
Mattel..................14...............847..............1.7%
Rockwell Autom..10...............544..............1.8%
FreeportMcMor.207...........8,512..............2.4%
Flowserve............13...............530..............2.5%
Kraft Foods..........91............3,642..............2.5%
Sara Lee...............13...............487..............2.7%
HJ Heinz..............39............1,374..............2.8%
Ingersoll-Rand.....29............1,007..............2.9%
FedEx..................79............2,265..............3.5%
Dover..................34...............925..............3.7%
Paccar.................25...............660..............3.8%
Fluor...................22...............560..............3.9%
Mosaic...............135............3,271..............4.1%
PPG Industries.....62............1,295..............4.8%
Coca Cola...........470...........9,709..............4.8%
Joy Global............33..............679..............4.9%
NewmontMining.214...........3,997..............5.4%
Cooper Industr....29...............530..............5.5%
Kellogg................97.............1,742..............5.6%
MeadJohnsnNutr.38...............634..............6.0%
Caterpillar.........247............3,750..............6.6%
Praxair..............133.............1,964..............6.8%
AirProd&Chem..101.............1,394..............7.2%
Avnet..................64...............871..............7.3%
Omnicom Grp....107............1,350..............7.9%
Ball Corp.............49...............606..............8.1%
CliffsNaturalRes.108............1,298..............8.3%
Goodrich.............67...............805..............8.3%
ArchDanMdlnd..251.............3,015..............8.3%
Raytheon...........205............2,432..............8.4%
Parker Hannifin..121.............1,414..............8.6%
KBR.....................56...............586..............9.6%
Lubrizol..............97............1,004..............9.7%
Yum Brands.......155............1,594..............9.7%
Wyndham WW.....55...............563..............9.8%
Total 56 Big Corps in
..Other22Sectors.2,558....106,434.............2.4%

Grand Total all Sectors
…175 Big Corps..(3,982)...565,660..........(0.7)%

Big Corp Tax Loophole Closer #51: Minimum Tax on Big Utility Profits

I found 36 Big US Utility Corps with Total Pretax Income above $1 bil each for the most recent three years. These 36 Big Utility Corps had a total effective US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid of a negative (1.2) % for 2010. And of these 36 Big Utility Corps, 18 of them, or 50%, had a negative US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid in 2010.

In comparison, the 2009 US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid of these 36 Big Utility Corps was a positive 3.4%, still very low.

Suffice it to say that if the US Government thinks that its Big US Utility Corps are helping reduce the US Deficit by paying a lot of US Federal Income Taxes, well…..good luck with that thought!

Here is the relevant 2010 financial information regarding these 36 US Big Utility Corps:

.................................Current US...........................Effective
.................................Fed Inc Tax..Consolidated...Tax Rate
................................Paid(Benefit).........PTI.......Paid(Benefit)
.....................................2010..............2010............2010
........................................(million of $s).....

PacifiCorp......................(498).............777...........(64.1)%
MidAmerican Energy.....(822)...........1,465...........(56.1)%
Edison International......(432)...........1,657...........(26.1)%
Pinnacle West Capital.....(109).............515...........(21.2)%
DTE Energy....................(172).............950...........(18.1)%
NiSource.........................(62)..............436...........(14.2)%
Consolidated Edison......(144)...........1,399...........(10.3)%
SCANA...........................(47)..............534.............(8.8)%
American Electric Pwr..(134)...........1,849.............(7.2)%
EQT................................(25)..............355.............(7.0)%
Constellation Energy(1)..(47)..............702.............(6.7)%
Public Service Enterpr..(166)............2,616.............(6.3)%
PPL................................(51)............1,239.............(4.1)%
CMS Energy....................(21)...............590.............(3.6)%
Progress Energy.............(46)............1,406.............(3.3)%
FirstEnergy....................(23)............1,242.............(1.9)%
PG&E..............................(12)............1,660.............(0.7)%
Duke Energy....................(5)............2,210.............(0.2)%
Nextera Energy................11............2,489...............0.4%
Alliant Energy...................3...............453...............0.7%
Allegheny Energy..............7...............628...............1.1%
Southern Co....................42............3,066...............1.4%
Xcel Energy.....................17............1,189...............1.4%
TECO Energy.....................6...............410...............1.5%
Northeast Utilities.............9...............605...............1.5%
Ameren...........................13...............476...............2.7%
Sempra Energy................27...............786...............3.4%
OGE Energy......................16...............461...............3.5%
CenterPoint Energy..........40..............705...............5.7%
Entergy..........................145............1,888...............7.7%
UGI Corp..........................61...............523.............11.7%
Exelon............................506............4,221.............12.0%
Dominion Resources.......891...........5,037..............17.7%
Wisconsin Energy...........145...............704.............20.6%
NRG Energy....................211...............753.............28.0%
NSTAR Electric...............122...............411.............29.7%

Total 36 Big Utilities......(544)........46,407.............(1.2)%

(1) Constellation Energy 2010 PTI excludes huge Asset Impairment Charge.

My proposal here is that all US Big Utility Corps should pay in US Federal Income Tax each year at least an amount equal to 10% of their Worldwide Pretax Income. That's not too much to ask, particularly in these horrible economic times, not just for US citizens and small businesses, but also for the US Debt Status.

When I run the detailed numbers on these Big Utility Corps, and use a conservative 5% average annual profit growth and 5% annual Federal Income Tax Paid growth from 2010 to 2021, I get additional US Federal Income Tax Receipts over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021 of $82.6 bil.

And if I use a 15% minimum Federal Income Tax Rate, rather than a 10% minimum tax rate, I get positive CBO scoring of $108.7 bil over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021 related to these 36 US Big Utility Corps.

Since such a high percentage of the income of US Big Utility Corps is received in the US, I think I would consider letting them have a portion of their income in each year not subject to a minimum tax, perhaps the first $100 mil.

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Whole-Scale US Infrastructure Investments with Optimal CBO Scoring

To maximize US job creation in the short term, there must be whole-scale US infrastructure investments made.

But also, it should be done in a way that optimizes upfront CBO scoring to the US Government, over the long run.

So, how do you do that? There are many smart ways to do this. Let me present four ideas.

First, on the front end, you lay out wise user fees that will apply to as many US infrastructure investments as you can. Thus, in upfront CBO scoring, an estimate must be made of the future user fees that the US Government will receive, which will reduce the overall long-term net cash outflow from the US infrastructure investment.

Second, if you make US infrastructure investments that are designed to reduce future energy costs, an estimate of these future energy cost savings should be factored into the upfront CBO scoring of the infrastructure project.

Third, I think for all US infrastructure investments, there should be upfront minimum percentage requirements of the total job cost that must be for labor costs. This minimum labor cost percentage should wisely vary by type of infrastructure project.

By having these upfront minimum labor cost percentage requirements, the upfront CBO scoring should include the additional US federal income taxes and US payroll taxes, both of which the US Government will be receiving, related to the minimum labor cost requirements of the US infrastructure projects.

And fourth, if the US Government, perhaps through the use of an Infrastructure Bank, provides wisely designed, highly incentivized financing for Infrastructure projects performed by outside entities, like State and Local Governments, and Non-Profit Hospitals and other Non-Profit Organizations, the interest to be collected by the US Government from the financing of the infrastructure project will result in upfront substantially positive CBO scoring to the US Government.

Optimal Fair Effective Corporate Federal Income Tax Reform

I would close all corporate federal income tax loopholes, except the clearly job-creating R&D tax credit, which should be made permanent, and with higher R&D tax credits going to the smaller businesses. And to be much more effective, the R&D tax credit must be simplified.

But I think that clearly the dumbest thing to do is what nearly every self-serving, short-sighted Republican is now proposing…..simply reduce the corporate federal income tax rate across the board, and watch the jobs trickle down from it. What absolute incredible lunacy.

If this were done, you would see almost no job creation from it, particularly in the near term. The only thing accomplished by across-the-board lower US Corporate Federal Income Tax Rates is much higher Corporate after-tax profits. Such a deal!

What has to be done to create a lot of jobs in the near term is massive short-term business tax incentives, like the investment tax credit, the jobs tax credit, and the R&D tax credit.….and all three tax credits done on a massive scale, and right away, and all earned only if the business gets a sufficient number of net jobs added, that must remain for a reasonable period of time, on a total company payroll count basis, or the tax credits are subsequently recaptured.

And the corporate federal income tax rates should also be permanently reduced, but it has to be done very wisely.

In addition to permanently lowering the US Federal Corporate Income Tax Rates on all US Corps, it is critical that this be accompanied by a very healthy US corporate federal minimum income tax, with progressive minimum tax rates applied as worldwide pretax income of each Big Corp rises (say the first $10 bil minimum taxed at 10%, the next $20 bil minimum taxed at 15%, the following $30 bil minimum taxed at 20%, and any worldwide income above $60 bil in each year minimum taxed at 25%).

And in all fairness, there should also be an annual level of worldwide pretax income that the minimum tax would not apply to, such as the first $100 mil earned in each year by each US business.

What the above minimum tax on large US Corps will accomplish is that instead of US Big Corps trying to shift income and jobs from the US to lower-taxed foreign tax havens, they will be motivated to instead do just the opposite.

Why? Because if a US Big Corp locates the jobs overseas in a foreign tax haven, it will still probably get a huge chunk of US federal income taxes owed, due to the very healthy, progressive US minimum tax that will apply.

In addition, to maximize US job creation, it only makes sense to have a lower Federal Corporate Income Tax Rate on small and medium-sized businesses, than that on large corporations. A wisely designed progressive US Corporate Federal Income Tax Rate system would maximize US job creation, and also be fairer to smaller businesses.

The Suits will have to run the numbers, but if all of the Corporate Tax Loopholes are closed, except for the R&D tax credit, then I think something like the following progressive US Corporate Federal Income Tax Rates would make sense, and optimally do the best for the US economy and US job creation, as well as also making a very substantial and fair dent in the US Debt, assuming the objective is to reduce Medicare Costs significantly, but not reduce Medicare Benefits:

Taxable Income Range.................Corporate Tax Rate

.....first $100,000.................................10%
.....$100,000 to $500,000...................14%
.....$500,000 to $1 mil.........................18%
.....$1 mil to $10 mil..............................22%
.....$10 mil to $100 mil.........................26%
.....$100 mil to $1 bil............................30%
.....above $1 bil.....................................34%

On the other hand, if all of the Corporate Tax Loopholes are closed, except for the R&D tax credit, then I think something like the following progressive US Corporate Federal Income Tax Rates would make sense, and optimally do the best for the US economy and US job creation, as well as also making a very substantial and fair dent in the US Debt, assuming the objective is to both reduce Medicare Costs significantly and also to reduce Medicare Benefits significantly:

Taxable Income Range.................Corporate Tax Rate

.....first $100,000.................................10%
.....$100,000 to $500,000...................13%
.....$500,000 to $1 mil.........................16%
.....$1 mil to $10 mil..............................19%
.....$10 mil to $100 mil.........................22%
.....$100 mil to $1 bil............................25%
.....above $1 bil.....................................28%

Monday, September 5, 2011

Big Corp Tax Loophole Closer #50: Minimum Tax on Other Sector Big Corp Worldwide Profits

So far, I have studied Big Corps in 6 Major US Sectors which have paid incredibly meager amounts of US Federal Income Taxes.

My recommendation is for the US Government to put a minimum US federal income tax on all of these US Big Corps, which should be used to fund a combination of wise US job creation, a US debt reduction, and a lower US Federal Income Tax Rate for all smaller and medium-sized US businesses.

Here is a summary of my projected positive CBO scoring to the US Government over the next 10 years, assuming this minimum US Federal Income Tax would be set at least at either 10% or 15% of Worldwide Consolidated Pretax Income of every US Big Corp in each year.

…………………….Positive CBO Scoring Next 10 Years
………………………………….................Minimum Tax
…………………………………................10%...........15%
………………………………...........(billions of US dollars)

Big US Oil Corps……………….........273.5………480.5
Big US Financial Corps………….....259.4………345.0
Big US Conglomerate Corps……...131.3……….163.0
Big US Health Care Corps………......95.2……….142.1
Big US High Tech Corps………….....73.0……….158.7
Big US Telecom Corps…………….....72.9……….110.2

Total of these 6 Major Sectors....905.3…….1,399.5

In this post, I am addressing US Big Corps in all of the other Non-Utility US Sectors, other than the above 6 Sectors.

Altogether, there were 67 US Big Corps in 22 Other US Sectors that had Total Consolidated Pretax Income of at least $1.5 bil each in the most recent three years, and which also paid an effective US Federal Income Tax Rate of below 15% in 2010. Included in these 67 US Big Corps are several somewhat smaller Corps which I was interested in.

Here is the relevant 2010 financial information regarding these 67 US Big Corps:

.................................Current US...........................Effective
.................................Fed Inc Tax..Consolidated...Tax Rate
................................Paid(Benefit).........PTI.......Paid(Benefit)
.....................................2010..............2010............2010
........................................(million of $s).....

Big Food and Beverage Corps
MolsonCoors Brewing.........8................809.............1.0%
Coca Cola Enterprises.........8................746.............1.1%
Bunge, Ltd(1)....................33.............3,050.............1.1%
Kraft Foods.......................91.............3,642.............2.5%
Sara Lee............................13................487.............2.7%
HJ Heinz...........................39.............1,374.............2.8%
Coca Cola(2)...................470............9,709.............4.8%
Kellogg.............................97.............1,742.............5.6%
Mead Johnson Nutrition...38................634.............6.0%
ArcherDanielsMidland....251.............3,015.............8.3%
PepsiCo...........................932.............8,232............11.3%
ConAgra Foods...............157.............1,225............12.8%
Total 12 Food&Bev.......2,137...........34,665.............6.2%

Big Chemical Corps
Dow Chemical...............(576)...........2,802..........(20.6)%
DuPont.........................(109)............3,711............(2.9)%
Mosaic...........................135.............3,271..............4.1%
PPG Industries................62..............1,295..............4.8%
Praxair..........................133..............1,964..............6.8%
Air Products&Chems.....101..............1,394..............7.2%
Lubrizol.........................97..............1,004..............9.7%
Total 7 Chemicals........(157)............15,441............(1.0)%

Big Household/Personal Product Corps
Fortune Brands.............(61)................588............(10.4)%
Avon Products..............(21)................945.............(2.2)%
Procter & Gamble.......1,809............15,158.............11.9%
Estee Lauder.................127..............1,026.............12.4%
Colgate Palmolive(3).....427..............3,430.............12.4%
Kimberly Clark..............368..............2,550.............14.4%
Total 6 HH and PPs.....2,649............23,697.............11.2%

Big Mining Corps
Southern Copper(1)........40...............2,431..............1.6%
Freeport-McMoran......207...............8,512..............2.4%
Newmont Mining(1)......214...............3,997..............5.4%
Cliff's Natural Res..........108...............1,298..............8.3%
Peabody Energy............114...............1,113.............10.2%
Total 5 Big Mining.........683.............17,351..............3.9%

Big Industrial Machinery Corps
Eaton.............................(2)..............1,036.............(0.2)%
Ingersoll-Rand(1)...........29..............1,007...............2.9%
Dover.............................34.................925...............3.7%
Parker Hannifin.............121..............1,414...............8.6%
Total 4 Industr Mach....182..............4,382...............4.2%

Big Leisure and Entertainment Corps
Carnival..........................0...............1,979...............0.0%
Royal Caribbean..............0.................548...............0.0%
Mattel............................14.................847...............1.7%
Wyndham WW................55................563................9.8%
Total 4 Leisure&Entert...69..............3,937...............1.8%

Big Electric Equipment Corps
Whirlpool...................(101)...............586...........(17.2)%
Rockwell Automation....10................544...............1.8%
Cooper Industries.........29................530...............5.5%
Amphenol(1)................77................664..............11.6%
Total 4 Electric Equip....15.............2,324...............0.6%

Big US Defense Contractor Corps
Boeing..........................13.............4,507...............0.3%
Goodrich......................67................805...............8.3%
Raytheon....................205.............2,432...............8.4%
Total 3 US Defense
.....Contractors............285............7,744...............3.7%

Big Retail Corps
Supervalu(4)..................2.................347...............0.6%
Yum Brands................155..............1,594...............9.7%
Staples........................142..............1,357.............10.5%
Total 3 Retail..............299..............3,298...............9.1%

Big Farm/Construction Machinery Corps
Cummins(1)..................11...............1,617...............0.7%
Caterpillar..................247..............3,750...............6.6%
Total 2 Big Farm
.....and Construction...258..............5,367...............4.8%

Big Wholesaler Corps
CHS(1)............................9.................584...............1.5%
Avnet...........................64.................871...............7.3%
Total 2 Wholesalers......73..............1,455...............5.0%

Big Engineering/Construction Corps
Fluor............................22................560...............3.9%
KBR..............................56................586...............9.6%
Total 2 Eng & Constr.....78..............1,146...............6.8%

Big Packaging/Container Corps
Crown Holdings..............0................614...............0.0%
Ball Corp.......................49................606...............8.1%
Total 2 Packaging
.....and Containers........49..............1,220..............4.0%

Big Misc Equipment Corps
Joy Global...................33.................679...............4.9%
Flowserve....................13.................530...............2.5%
Total 2 Misc Equip.......46..............1,209...............3.8%

Big Transportation Corps
FedEx.........................79..............2,265...............3.5%
United Parcel Serv....776..............5,523..............14.1%
Total 2 Big
.....Transportation.....855.............7,788..............11.0%

Big Tobacco Corp
Phillip Morris Intl......157............10,324...............1.5%

Big Cogeneration Power Producer
AES(4).........................(8).............2,265.............(0.4)%

Big Advertising Agency Corp
Omnicom Group........107..............1,350...............7.9%

Big Forest/Paper Product Corp
Intl Paper................(249)................822............(30.3)%

Big Metal Corp
Nucor.......................(66)................267.............(24.7)%

Big Motor Vehicles/Parts Corp
Paccar........................25.................660.................3.8%

Big Apparel/Footwear Corp
Nike..........................289..............2,844................10.2%

Grand Total (67 Corps
….in 22 Sectors)
..7,776..........149,556.................5.2%

(1) Above Current US Federal Income Tax also includes US State Income Tax.
(2) Coca Cola PTI excludes various large unusual transactions.
(3) Colgate Palmolive US Federal Income Tax also includes US State Income Tax and also all US Deferred Income Tax Expense.
(4) PTI excludes large Intangible Asset Impairments.


My proposal here is that all US Big Corps in these Other Sectors should pay in US Federal Income Tax each year at least an amount equal to 10% of their Worldwide Pretax Income. That's not too much to ask, particularly in these horrible economic times, not just for US citizens and small businesses, but also for the US Debt Status.

When I run the detailed numbers on these Big Other Sector Corps, and use a 10% average annual profit growth and 10% annual Federal Income Tax Paid growth from 2010 to 2021, I get additional US Federal Income Tax Receipts over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021 of $155.9 bil. When added to the similar earlier mentioned $905.3 bil related to the 6 Sectors I had already studied, that brings the total positive CBO scoring to the US Government to $1,061.2 bil.

And if I use a 15% minimum Federal Income Tax Rate, rather than a 10% minimum tax rate, I get positive CBO scoring of $282.7 bil over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021 related to these 67 US Big Corps in these 22 Other Sectors. When added to the similar earlier mentioned $1,395.5 bil related to the 6 Sectors I had already studied, that brings the total positive CBO scoring to $1,682.2 bil…..yeah, almost $1.7 trillion.

Perhaps the best way to go on a minimum tax on US Big Other Sector Corps would be to apply a 10% minimum US Federal Income Tax on the first $10 bil of annual Worldwide Pretax Income, then a 15% minimum tax on any annual Worldwide Pretax Income in excess of $10 bil and up to $20 bil, and then a 20% minimum tax on any annual Worldwide Pretax Income in excess of $20 bil.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Big Corp Tax Loophole Closer #49: Minimum Tax on Big Conglomerate Worldwide Profits

For the 10 US Big Conglomerate Corps as I define them, with Total Pretax Income above $1.5 bil each for the most recent three years, the total effective US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid was a very modest 6.4%. And for the most recent year 2010, this effective tax rate was an even lower 3.1%.

Here are these 10 Big US Conglomerate Corps applicable amounts for 2010:

.................................Current US...........................Effective
.................................Fed Inc Tax..Consolidated...Tax Rate
................................Paid(Benefit).........PTI.......Paid(Benefit)
.....................................2010..............2010............2010
........................................(million of $s).....

Big US Conglomerates
GE...............................(3,253)..........14,208..........(22.9)%
Honeywell......................(471)............2,843..........(16.6)%
United Technologies........122.............6,538.............1.9%
Tyco Intl...........................45.............1,270.............3.5%
Loews..............................154.............2,902.............5.3%
Johnson Controls.............112.............1,763.............6.4%
3M...................................837............5,755............14.5%
Danaher...........................388.............2,342............16.6%
ITT...................................152................818............18.6%
Berkshire Hathaway(1)..3,668...........19,051............19.3%

Total of all 10................1,754..........57,490.............3.1%

(1) Berkshire Hathaway above US Federal Income Tax includes Current US Federal, US State and Foreign Income Tax Expense amounts.

My proposal here is that all US Big Conglomerate Corps should pay in US Federal Income Tax each year at least an amount equal to 10% of their Worldwide Pretax Income. That's not too much to ask, particularly in these horrible economic times, not just for US citizens and small businesses, but also for the US Debt Status.

When I run the detailed numbers on these Big Conglomerate Corps, and use a 10% average annual profit growth and 10% annual Federal Income Tax Paid growth from 2011 to 2021, I get additional US Federal Income Tax Receipts over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021 of $131.3 bil.

And if I use a 15% minimum Federal Income Tax Rate, rather than a 10% minimum tax rate, I get positive CBO scoring of $163.0 bil over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021.

Perhaps the best way to go on a minimum tax on US Big Conglomerate Corps would be to apply a 10% minimum US Federal Income Tax on the first $10 bil of annual Worldwide Pretax Income, then a 15% minimum tax on any annual Worldwide Pretax Income in excess of $10 bil and up to $20 bil, and then a 20% minimum tax on any annual Worldwide Pretax Income in excess of $20 bil.

All of the tax receipts here should be used to reduce the US Debt.

I think it would be wise to take a closer historical look at GE Consolidated to see if we can get a better clue on just why the country is in such horrible economic straits presently.

From their audited financial statements and related income tax footnotes filed with the SEC, here's GE Consolidated Pretax Income and US Federal Income Taxes Paid or (Tax Benefits Received) during the 8 Clinton Presidential Years from 1993 to 2000, and then during the 10 subsequent years from 2001 to 2010, with the bulk of these later years being the 8 Bush/Cheney Presidential Years from 2001 to 2008:

..............................................................US Federal........Effective
....................................Consolidated....Income Tax.....US Fed Inc
...................................Pretax Income..Paid(Benefit).Tax Rate Paid
..........................................(in millions of dollars)
Clinton Presidential Years
1993.................................6,136................1,126
1994.................................8,661................1,299
1995.................................9,737...............1,409
1996...............................10,806..................971
1997...............................11,179................1,176
1998...............................13,477................1,459
1999...............................15,577................1,632
2000..............................18,446................3,005...........16.3%
Total Clinton 8 Yrs......94,019..............12,077...........12.8%

Subsequent 10 Years
2001.............................19,701.................2,514
2002.............................18,891....................137
2003.............................19,904.................1,555
2004.............................20,106.................1,839
2005.............................21,178.................2,755...........13.0%
2006.............................23,330....................514............2.2%
2007.............................26,598......................87............0.3%
2008.............................19,770..................(651)..........(3.3)%
2009...............................9,995..................(833)..........(8.3)%
2010.............................14,208................(3,253)........(22.9)%
Total 10 Yrs 2001-10..193,681.................4,664............2.4%

Yeah, that's right, during the 8 years of the Clinton Presidency, GE Consolidated generated Total Consolidated Pretax Income of $94.0 bil, and paid what seemed like a pretty fair amount of Total US Federal Income Tax of $12.1 bil, which resulted in an effective tax rate paid of 12.8%.

And what has happened in the 10 years since then?.....8 of which were the Bush/Cheney Presidential years, and also most of which had the US House Ways and Means Committee and the US Senate Finance Committee both in Republican control.

Well, in these 10 years from 2000 to 2010, GE Consolidated generated Total Consolidated Pretax Income of $193.7 bil, and paid Total US Federal Income Tax of only $4.7 bil, or an incredibly low effective tax rate paid of 2.4%.

Do you really think that GE wants a Democratic President in 2012? And do you really think that GE wants a US House Ways and Means and US Senate Finance Committee under Democratic control in 2012? GE's CEO works for his stockholders, not for the Obama Administration.

I have a hunch that GE, just like nearly all of the US Big Corps that have paid so very little in US Federal Income Taxes under Bush/Cheney and under Republican House and Republican Senate control, will do everything in their power to prevent the Obama Administration, and the Democrats in both the US Senate and in the US House, from being successful in their clearly laser-like focus on substantial US job creation in both the short run and in the long run.

And the CEO of GE is now in charge of US Jobs? What motivation does he have to be successful here in creating US jobs? I suggest he has absolutely none.

When you think about it, with the incredible tax benefits that GE Consolidated has received over the past 10 years, while so many of the country's citizens and its small businesses have been suffering so severely, US citizens have to be outraged, particularly at the US House Ways and Means Committee, and to a somewhat lesser extent, at the US Senate Finance Committee, for permitting this to happen. With the US economy in such shambles for everyone other than US Big Corps, I think it is in the country's best interests that anyone presently on the US House Ways and Means Committee, who continues to shirk his critical responsibility, should be moved to a less critical US House Committee, and replaced by someone who wants to move both the US economy and US job creation forward.

Big Corp Tax Loophole Closer #48: Minimum Tax on Big Telecom Profits

For the 13 US Big Telecommunication Corps with Total Pretax Income above $1.5 bil each for the most recent three years, the total effective US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid was a very modest 7.6%. And for the most recent year 2010, this effective tax rate was an even lower 6.1%.

Here are the 6 of these 13 Big US Telecom Corps that had an effective US Federal Income Tax Rate Paid below 10% in 2010:

...............................Current US.............................Effective
...............................Fed Inc Tax....Consolidated...Tax Rate
..............................Paid(Benefit)...........PTI.......Paid(Benefit)
...................................2010................2010............2010
......................................(million of $s).....

US Big Telecom
Verizon Commun........(705)..............12,684..........(5.6)%
Qwest Commun..............(14)..................925...........(1.5)%
NII Holdings.....................0...................598............0.0%
AT&T............................307..............18,238............1.7%
Time Warner Cable........127................2,196............5.8%
CBS.................................89................1,222............7.3%

Total all 6 Telecom......(196).............35,863...........(0.5)%

My proposal here is that all US Big Telecom Corps should pay in US Federal Income Tax each year at least an amount equal to 10% of their Worldwide Pretax Income. That's not too much to ask, particularly in these horrible economic times, not just for US citizens and small businesses, but also for the US Debt Status.

When I run the detailed numbers on these Big Telecom Corps, and use a 10% average annual profit growth and 10% annual Federal Income Tax Paid growth from 2010 to 2021, I get additional US Federal Income Tax Receipts over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021 of $72.9 bil. And 92% of this positive CBO scoring just relates to the two US Big Telecom Giants.....AT&T and Verizon.

And if I use a 15% minimum Federal Income Tax Rate, rather than a 10% minimum tax rate, I get positive CBO scoring of $110.2 bil over the 10 years from 2012 to 2021.

Perhaps the best way to go on a minimum tax on US Big Telecom Corps would be to apply a 10% minimum US Federal Income Tax on the first $10 bil of annual Worldwide Pretax Income, then a 15% minimum tax on any annual Worldwide Pretax Income in excess of $10 bil and up to $20 bil, and then a 20% minimum tax on any annual Worldwide Pretax Income in excess of $20 bil.

All of the tax receipts here should be used to reduce the US Debt.