Thursday, November 10, 2011

US Big Retail Corps 3Q 2011 Earnings Growth was Moderate

Forty-eight US Big Retail Corps, with Pretax Earnings or Losses above $100 mil each, in any of the first three quarters of either 2011 or 2010, have released their 3Q 2011 earnings.

These 48 US Big Retail Corps registered a Total Pretax Earnings increase of 6% in the 3Q 2011 over the prior year's quarter, decelerating a bit from both the 7% earnings growth in the 2Q 2011 and the 10% earnings growth registered in the 1Q 2011.

Here's how the US Big Retail Sector earnings growth of 6% in the 3Q 2011 stacks up with US Big Oil and US Big Financial.

3Q 2011 Pretax Earnings Growth over 3Q 2010:

.....48 US Big Retail Corps.......................................6%
......4 US Largest Credit Card Corps.......................23%
......7 US Largest Financial Corps..........................25%
.....21 US Next Largest National/Regional Banks...38%
......6 US Largest Oil Corps....................................57%
......7 US Next Largest Oil Corps..........................107%

I don't think it is good for the US economy for its high-quality Retail sector's 3Q 2011 earnings growth to trail that of both the US Big Oil sector and the US Big Financial sector by such an incredibly wide gap. I think this gives a good insight into why there is such a huge wealth gap between the 1%ers and the 99% rest of the country, the Occupy Movement's major beef.

The overall US economy and US job creation won't improve dramatically until this earnings growth gap between both US Big Oil and US Big Financial vs. the rest of the US business sectors, including all of small business, is substantially closed.

Below here are these 3Q 2011 Pretax Earnings (PTI), along with a comparison with the prior year’s 3Q 2010 amounts, for these 48 Big US Retailers.

.......................................................................Increase
..........................................PTI(L)......PTI(L).......(Decrease)
.............................................3Q.........3Q..................
...........................................2011......2010....Amount....%
.............................................(millions of dollars)

Walmart 5,805 5,705 100 2%
McDonalds 2,263 1,975 288 15%
Home Depot 2,148 1,901 247 13%
CVS Caremark 1,429 1,341 88 7%
Lowes 1,329 1,335 (6) 0%
Target 1,109 1,081 28 3%
Walgreens(1) 817 728 89 12%
Costco 772 684 88 13%
Medco Health Solutions 589 613 (24) -4%
TJX 559 496 63 13%
Express Scripts 517 488 29 6%
Starbucks 504 413 91 22%
Publix Super Markets 478 438 40 9%
Kohls 475 410 65 16%
Autozone 470 423 47 11%
Yum Brands 456 506 (50) -10%
Macy's 395 240 155 65%
Kroger 391 392 (1) 0%
Bed Bath & Beyond 370 297 73 25%
Coach 321 285 36 13%
GAP 313 398 (85) -21%
Nordstrom 290 240 50 21%
Limited Brands 276 244 32 13%
Best Buy 259 403 (144) -36%
Ross Stores 242 210 32 15%
Staples 237 212 25 12%
Oreilly Automotive 235 190 45 24%
Dollar General 231 225 6 3%
Safeway 196 178 18 10%
CarMax 181 175 6 3%
Advanced Auto Parts 169 140 29 21%
Fastenol 155 121 34 28%
Dollar Tree 152 125 27 22%
Darden Restaurants 147 159 (12) -8%
Tiffany 131 102 29 28%
Amazon 130 292 (162) -55%
Family Dollar Stores 125 112 13 12%
Whole Foods Market 119 95 24 25%
AutoNation 116 94 22 23%
Petsmart 96 77 19 25%
Supervalu(2) 96 74 22 30%
Foot Locker 58 10 48 480%
GameStop 47 60 (13) -22%
Dillards 24 8 16 200%
JC Penney 24 18 6 33%
Sothebys (58) (38) (20) -53%
Rite Aid(3) (95) (194) 99 51%
Sears Holding (238) (53) (185) -349%

Total 48 Big Retail 24,855 23,428 1,427 6%

(1) Walgreen's 2011 PTI excludes large gain on sale of business.
(2) Supervalu 2010 PTI excludes large intangible asset impairment charge.
(3) Rite Aid 2010 PTI excludes loss on debt modification charge.

Liquidate Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

The way it works right now, the US Government, and thus also US citizens, can’t win economically, it can only lose, by continuing to make additional capital contributions to fund the continuing massive annual losses of Fannie and Freddie. When you have no upside, but certain downside, you clearly have to change the situation.

I am not a lawyer so I don’t know legally how best to do it, but after researching these two companies in depth, let me give a quick overview of the steps I think should be taken, and where we should end up to best change this horrible economic situation with Fannie and Freddie, that has wreaked havoc on the US economy, and on US job creation.

First, I think that the US Government, or some US Government Agency, should now acquire, at a net purchase price at net fair market value, all of the assets, and assume all of the liabilities, of both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Second, I think the US Government should write down the interest rates significantly on all of the mortgage loans it acquires from Fannie and Freddie.

Third, for any homeowner of any underwater, or a bit above water, mortgage loan, who agrees to it, I think the US Government should write-down the home mortgage it acquired to somewhere in the range of 80% or 90% of the appraised value of the home.

Fourth, I think perhaps 20 to 50 new independent privately-held, or to be set up as independent new publicly-held, companies, as well as any existing small bank, should be permitted to each acquire from the US Government, at a shade below fair market value, a percentage that in the aggregate initially totals say 10% of the mortgage loans initially held by the US Government. Thus, the US Government should initially retain say 90% of these home mortgages.

Fifth, over time, the US Government should sell the additional 90% of these mortgage loans to these 20 to 50 companies, or to any small bank.

Sixth, the US Government will retain all the liabilities of both Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, pay interest on them, if any, based on their contract terms, and eventually liquidate them based on their contract repayment terms. The US Government also has the opportunity to liquidate the obligations early by buying them in the open market.

These actions will spur substantial US economic growth, and US job creation. There will be substantially more income in US consumers hands that can be spent in the US economy. Also, the presently low consumer confidence will increase precipitously.

And when I do the math, any fair CBO scoring should yield a very positive net cash inflow to the US Government over the next 10 years, and on to infinity.

The massive continuing losses of Fannie and Freddie, which the US Government and thus also US citizens are funding, would be stopped.

Let me show how large these Pretax Losses of Fannie and Freddie have been in the most recent 5 years, since 2007.


……………..Fannie…...Freddie…....Total
…………….......(millions of dollars)…….

2007.......(5,147).....(5,977)....(11,124)
2008.....(44,570)...(44,564)....(89,134)
2009....(73,007)...(22,384)....(95,391)
2010.....(14,100)...(14,882)....(28,982)
2011*....(14,539)....(6,247)....(20,786)

Total...(151,363)...(94,054)..(245,417)

* 9 Months September 2011

Yeah, that’s $245 bil of Pretax Losses in the past just less than 5 years.

Also, Fannie Mae has incurred Total Derivative Losses, which have been reflected in its Pretax Losses or Pretax Income, of $71.9 bil in the past 10 years. Freddie Mac has generated Total Derivative Losses and Costs of $50.7 bil in the past 8 years. And these Derivative Losses occurred in every year for each of these two companies.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Fannie Mae 3Q 2011 $5.1 Bil Loss, Higher Than Both $3.0 Bil Loss in 2Q 2011 and $1.3 Bil Loss in 3Q 2010

Fannie Mae was plugging along just fine in the early and middle parts of the 2000s Decade, when it generated the following annual Pretax Incomes:

2002……$4.8 bil
2003….$10.3 bil
2004……$6.0 bil
2005……$7.6 bil
2006……$4.2 bil

But then some trouble started to happen in 2007, when this string of annual profits, occurring for many years, reversed course and turned into a 2007 Pretax Loss of $5.1 bil.

This $9.3 Profit Decline in 2007 from 2006 was caused mainly by three factors.

First, its Provision for Credit Losses, including on its Loan Losses, its Guarantee Losses and its Losses on Certain Guarantee Contracts, were stepped up dramatically from $1.0 bil in 2006 to $6.0 bil in 2007. Thus even before the complete financial meltdown in 2008, somebody at Fannie Mae, or at its external CPA firm, presciently sniffed out the coming bad winds, which eventually turned into a devastating tornado, in the real estate market.

Second, Fannie Mae incurred Derivative Losses of $4.1 bil in 2007, as compared with a much lower $1.5 bil in 2006.

And third, Fannie Mae recorded Net Interest Income of $4.6 bil, as compared with a much higher $6.8 bil in 2006.

Then the real estate tornado hit, with Fannie Mae recording Pretax Losses as follows: $44.6 bil in 2008, $76.0 bil in 2009, $14.1 bil in 2010.

So while these losses are just huge, the one positive aspect is that they declined sharply in 2010.

But that’s the best it gets.

In 2011, Fannie Mae generated Pretax Losses as follows: $6.5 bil in the 1Q, $3.0 bil in the 2Q, and now $5.1 bil in the most recent 3Q 2011. Thus for the first 9 months of 2011, its $14.5 bil Pretax Loss already exceeds the annual Pretax Loss of $14.1 bil generated in 2010.

And this 3Q 2011 $5.1 bil Loss was 279% higher than the 3Q 2010 Loss of $1.3 bil.

From its SEC filings, below here is a very condensed summary of Fannie Mae’s Income Statements for the 3Q 2011, as compared with the 3Q 2010.

..............................................................................Increase
.................................................3Q...........3Q........(Decrease)
...............................................2011.......2010....Amount....%
..............................................(millions of dollars)

Net Interest Income..............5,186......4,776........410........9%
Provision for Loan Losses....(4,159)....(4,696).......537.......11%
Derivative FV Losses.....(4,255)......(124)..(4,131).(3331)%
Trading Securities
…...FV Gains(Losses)..............(214)........889.....(1,103)...(124)%
Administrative Expenses.......(591).......(730)........139.......19%
Foreclosed Property Exp......(733).......(787)..........54........7%
Other-net..............................(319).......(668).........349.......52%
=Pretax Loss......................(5,085)....(1,340)....(3,745)...(279)%

Clearly, just like was the case with Freddie Mac, the Fannie Mae Losses were driven predominantly by the Derivative Fair Value Losses.

In fact, absent the 3Q 2011 Derivative Losses of $4.3 bil, Fannie Mae would have lowered its Pretax Loss to $.8 bil. And the massive $4.1 bil Derivative Loss increase from the 3Q 2010 was higher than the $3.7 bil increase in the Total Pretax Loss from the 3Q 2010.

Fannie Mae’s Provision for Loan Losses of $4.1 bil in the 3Q 2011 was huge, but still a bit lower than the $4.7 bil recorded in the 3Q 2010.

And below here is a very condensed summary of Fannie Mae’s Income Statements for the lst 9 months Sept 2011, as compared with the lst 9 months 2010.

..............................................9 Mos.....9 Mos.....Increase
..............................................Sept........Sept.....(Decrease)
..............................................2011.......2010.....Amount.......%
..............................................(millions of dollars)

Net Interest Income............15,118.....11,772......3,346......28%
ProvisionforLoanLoss(20,548).(20,930)......382........2%
Derivative FV Losses....(5,793)...(3,283)...(2,510)...(76)%
Trading Securities FV Gains.....146......2,587.....(2,441)....(94)%
Administrative Expenses...(1,765)....(2,005)........240.......12%
Foreclosed Property Exp......(743)....(1,255).........512.......41%
Other-net..............................(954)....(1,036)..........82.........8%

=Pretax Loss....................(14,539)...(14,150)......(389)......(3)%

The Net Interest Income increase of $3.3 bil is driven by the lower Interest Expense from a decline in interest rates. And yes, the Provision for Loan Losses exceeds the Net Interest Income by $5.4 bil in the first 9 months of 2011 and by $9.2 bil in the first 9 months of 2010.

More than offsetting this increase in Net Interest Income of $3.3 bil were higher Derivative Fair Value Losses of $2.5 bil, and lower Fair Value Trading Securities Gains of $2.4 bil.

I think it is wise to take a longer term look at key aspects of Fannie Mae’s historic income statements.

From its SEC filings, I’ll first analyze its annual Provision for Credit Losses. This is a combination of its Provision for Loan Losses, its Provision for Guarantee Losses, and its Losses on Certain Guarantee Contracts.

Just like Freddie Mac, prior to 2007, Fannie Mae recorded meager amounts of Provision for Credit Losses, especially given Fannie Mae’s huge Loans and Loan Guarantees. Let me lay these out since 2002:

2002…….........$284 mil
2003….…........$365 mil
2004…...…......$352 mil
2005…...........$587 mil
2006…........$1,028 mil
2007...........$5,988 mil
2008.........$27,951 mil
2009.........$72,626 mil
2010.........$24,896 mil
2011..........$21,242 mil*

* 9 Months ended Sept 2011

Frankly, it doesn’t make sense to me why the Provisions for Credit Losses were so low before the financial meltdown. The amounts of Loans and Loan Guarantees were massive. Certainly more than these above meager amounts of bad loans should have been provided for back then.

Also, it seems to me that the 2008 Provision for Credit Losses of $28.0 bil is way too low. The massive financial meltdown occurred in 2008, but yet the following year’s Provision in 2009 was a massive $44.7 bil higher than that provided in 2008. There is no logical match with when the loans should have been determined to be bad, and when the Provisions for Credit Losses were booked.

Likewise, the $25 bil additional Provision in 2010 seems really strange to me, since it’s only 11% lower than the Provision booked in 2008, when the complete financial meltdown occurred.

Further, I think the real economic damage of these Loans is much less in 2011 than the huge Provision for Credit Losses booked so far in the current year.

And second, and most important of all, what in the world is going on with all of these massive Derivative Losses, which are imbedded in the Income Statement report line that Fannie Mae calls “Fair Value Gains and Losses"?

Let me lay out the components of these Fair Value Gains and Losses, reflected in Fannie Mae’s annual earnings, since 2002.

.................................Trading
................................Securities...............Other.......Total
..............Derivative....Fair......Hedged....Fair........Fair
...................Fair........Value....Mortgage..Value......Value
..................Value.......Gains.......Asset.....Gains.......Gains
...............(Losses)....(Losses)....Gains...(Losses)...(Losses)
.......................(millions of dollars)............................

2002........(12,919)...............................................(12,919)
2003.........(6,289).................................................(6,289)
2004........(12,256)..............................................(12,256)
2005.........(4,196).................................................(4,196)
2006.........(1,522)...........8.....................(230)......(1,744)
2007.........(4,113)......(365)....................(190)......(4,668)
2008........(15,416)..(7,040).....2,154.......173......(20,129)
2009.........(6,350)....3,744.....................(205)......(2,811)
2010.........(3,000)....2,692.....................(203).........(511)
2011*........(5,793).......146.....................(223)......(5,870)

Total.......(71,854)....(815)......2,154......(878).....(71,393)

* 9 Months Sept 2011

When you review the above numbers, the entire Total Fair Value Loss of $71.4 bil is more than matched by the Total Derivative Losses of $71.9 bil.

Wasn’t it Albert Einstein who defined Insanity as “doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results”?

In none of these years, did Fannie have Derivative Gains, and the total Derivative Losses are more than $71 bil! And when you combine Freddie Mac's more than $50 bil of Total Derivative Losses, you get more than $120 bil in Derivative Losses for Fannie and Freddie combined.

If I understand this correctly, if Fannie Mae would not have engaged in any derivatives, it would have had higher earnings of more than $71 bil over the past 10 years. And then Freddie Mac would have had more than $50 bil of higher earnings, if it would not have engaged in any derivatives.

I think the Las Vegas casinos would love to see Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac sitting at their gambling tables, and they would lay out the red carpet for them, would comp them lavishly, and would want them to stay as long as possible.

I think the question the US Government should be asking is just who profited from these more than $120 bil of Derivative Losses related to Fannie and Freddie, and how much money did they each make on them?

I think the US Government, including the US Congress and their staffs, have enough people working on the housing crisis, including reviewing what is going on with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.

But I also think the reason the housing crisis hasn’t been substantially improved, including the problems with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, is that the US Government doesn’t have enough very bright people, who also have the requisite financial expertise, who are working on these very complex housing crisis issues, so critical to improving the US economy, and US job creation.

The US Congress has done nothing of substance that effectively deals with the housing issue. And I think that all of the Feds responsible for reviewing, and taking wise subsequent actions on, what has been going on with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, haven’t effectively done their jobs.

And Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have the power to keep underwater homeowners from getting their mortgage interest rates, and perhaps even their mortgage principal balances, reduced? That's not right, and not even close to being right.

The Occupy Movement, and their 99% supporters, are spot on in identifying the housing crisis as one where there clearly has not been enough progress made.

And just the thought of Fannie Mae throwing $71 bil away and Freddie Mac throwing $50 bil away in the past 8 to 10 years by making bad, or at least less than optimal, Derivative decisions is enough to make the 99%ers, many of whom have underwater mortgages, intensely angry.

So the Deficit Reduction Super-committee is thinking of reducing Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security Benefits, while at the same time, not taking the proper actions to substantially reduce both Fannie Mae's and Freddie Mac's recurring, massive Derivative Losses? That's also not right.....not even close to being right.

US Publicly-Held Big Hospital 3Q 2011 Earnings Rock, While Patients Get Rolled

From SEC filings, below here are the 3Q 2011 Pretax Earnings (PTI), along with a comparison to the prior year’s 3Q 2010 amounts, of the 8 US Publicly-held Hospital and Related Health Care Services Corps, which have released their 3Q Earnings so far, through today November 9, 2011.

......................................................PTI...PTI(L).....Increase.......
......................................................3Q.......3Q.......(Decrease)....
....................................................2011...2010..Amount..%..
......................................................(millions of dollars)

HCA(1)..................................TN....529.....468.......61.....13%
Davita...................................CO....259.....218.......41.....19%
Universal Health Systems......PA...147.......93.......54.....58%
Community Health Systems..TN....133.....131.........2.......2%
Health Mgt Associates...........FL.....72.......60.......12.....20%
LifePoint Hospitals................TN.....62.......55........7......13%
United Surgical Partners.......TX......41.......33........8......24%
Tenet Healthcare(2)..............TX......21......(7)......28....400%

Total of all 8...............................1,264...1,051....213.....20%

(1) HCA 2011 PTI excludes Loss on Debt Retirement.
(2) Tenet Healthcare 2010 PTI excludes Loss on Debt Retirement.

Yeah, these 8 Big Hospital and Health Care Related Services Corps had their 3Q 2011 Pretax Income increase sharply by 20%. And all 8 of them registered earnings increases.

The Occupying Movement, and most of its 99% supporters, are clearly aware of what continues to be going on in the Hospital Industry.....exorbitant patient service pricing.

What these outsized profits of the entire Hospital Industry, both publicly-held hospitals and the massive Non-Profit hospitals, are telling us is that the US Government simply needs to legislate for a substantial reduction in the amounts that Medicare pays to hospitals and related health care organizations for elderly patient services.

The Deficit Reduction Super-committee should substantially reduce Medicare payments to hospitals, rather than focusing on reducing Medicare benefits of retirees. And the same goes for Medicaid payments.

This is how you best bend the long term health care cost curve, and in a fair and wise manner.

============================================

Late Addition Big Hospitals Not Included in the Above Charts

......................................................PTI.....PTI.....Increase.......
......................................................3Q.......3Q.....(Decrease)....
....................................................2011...2010..Amount..%..
......................................................(millions of dollars)

Mednax..................................FL.....94.....81.......13.....16%
Psychiatric Solutions.............TN.....87.....46.......41.....89%
Amsurg..................................TN.....56.....52........4.......8%
Healthsouth...........................AL.....52.....38.......14.....37%
Magellan Health....................MD.....36.....73.....(37)...(51)%

Total of all 5..................................325....290......35.....12%

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

US Big Pharma 3Q 2011 Earnings Rock, While Drug Consumers Get Rolled

From SEC filings, below here are the 3Q 2011 Pretax Earnings (PTI), along with a comparison to the prior year’s 3Q 2010 amounts, of the 6 US Big Pharma Corps.

..........................................PTI..........PTI..........Increase.......
..........................................3Q............3Q..........(Decrease)....
........................................2011........2010.....Amount....%..
..........................................(millions of dollars)
US Big Pharma
JNJ(1)............................4,427.......4,219.........208.......5%
Pfizer(2).........................3,906.......3,795.........111.......3%
Merck(3)........................2,216.......1,448.........768......53%
Abbott Labs(4)..............2,002.......1,253.........749......60%
Bristol Myers Squibb......1,830.......1,614.........216......13%
Eli Lilly..........................1,503.......1,671........(168)....(10)%

Total 6 Big Pharma.......15,884.....14,000.......1,884....13%

(1) JNJ 2011 PTI excludes Currency Option Adjustments and Planned Acquisition Deal Cost Charges.
(2) Pfizer 2011 and 2010 PTI both exclude Asset Impairment Charges and Additional Legal Charges. Its 2010 PTI also excludes Inventory Write Off Charge from an older acquisition.
(3) Merck 2011 PTI excludes Gain on Joint Venture Divestiture. Its 2010 PTI excludes Additional Legal Reserve Charge.
(4) Abbott Labs 2011 PTI exludes massive Litigation Charges re Depakote. Its 2010 PTI excludes Intangible Asset Impairment Charge.

Yeah, that's correct, while the 99%ers are paying incredibly high prices for their drugs, the 6 US Big Pharma Corps register very robust Pretax Profits, which increased 13% in the 3Q 2011. And in addition, these Big Pharma Corps are getting a massive tax benefit from shifting their income to foreign tax havens, including to Puerto Rico.

The 99%ers have a very difficult time understanding how the Deficit Reduction Super-committee can continue to let these US Big Pharma Corps generate year-after-year of very robust profits, which get an additional massive kick from the majority of this worldwide income being taxed in foreign tax havens.

And in a excessive greed pile on, the US Big Pharma Corps now are lobbying heavily the US Government to permit them to repatriate these exceeding low income taxed foreign earnings at an incredibly low US federal income tax rate. And people want to know why the Occupy Movement has so many supporters? Someone has to fight against Big Corp dominance of the US Congress. It is devastating economically the country's 99%ers.

Also, it is very difficult for me to understand how it is right for the Deficit Reduction Super-committee to decide to reduce Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security benefits, while at the same time, not permitting the US Government to negotiate for fairer drug prices with the large drug companies, including the foreign ones.

And below here are the 3Q 2011 Pretax Earnings (PTI), along with a comparison to the prior year’s 3Q 2010 amounts, of the 8 US Other Drug Corps, which have Pretax Income (PTI) of at least $100 mil in either the 3Q 2011 or in the 3Q 2010.

............................................PTI..........PTI..........Increase.......
............................................3Q............3Q..........(Decrease)....
..........................................2011........2010.....Amount....%..
............................................(millions of dollars)
Other Large Drug Corps
Celgene...............................413..........330...........83......25%
Allergan(1).........................357..........251..........106......42%
Forest Labs.........................319..........371.........(52)....(14)%
Mylan Labs.........................192..........132...........60......45%
Watson Pharma(2)..............119..........104...........15......14%
Endo Pharma(3).................113..........103...........10......10%
Perrigo................................89..........102.........(13)....(13)%
Warner Chilcott Ltd.............76..........113.........(37)....(33)%

Total 8 Other Drug Corps.1,678.......1,506.........172......11%

(1) Allergan 2010 PTI excludes Legal Settlement Charge and Intangible Asset Impairment Charge.
(2) Watson Pharmceuticals 2010 PTI excludes Drug Pricing Litigation Charge.
(3) Endo Pharmaceuticals 2011 PTI excludes Asset Impairment Charge.

Monday, November 7, 2011

Freddie Mac 2Q 2011 $2.4 bil Loss Accelerated to a $4.5 bil Loss in 3Q 2011

Freddie Mac was plugging along just fine, when it generated Pretax Incomes of $2.5 bil in 2005 and $2.3 bil in 2006, but then some trouble started to happen in 2007, when this string of annual profits, occurring for many years, reversed course and turned into a 2007 Pretax Loss of $6.0 bil.

This $8.3 Profit Decline in 2007 from 2006 was caused by several factors.

First, its Provision for Credit Losses were stepped up dramatically from $.3 bil in 2006 to $2.9 bil in 2007. Thus even before the complete financial meltdown in 2008, somebody at Freddie Mac, or at its external CPA firm, presciently sniffed out the coming bad winds, which eventually turned into a devastating tornado, in the real estate market.

Second, Freddie Mac incurred a Foreign Currency Loss of $2.3 bil in 2007.

Third, Freddie Mac incurred a Loss on Loans Purchased of $1.9 bil in 2007.

And fourth, Freddie Mac incurred Losses on certain credit guarantees of $2.0 bil in 2007, much higher than such Losses in 2006 of $.4 bil

Then the real estate tornado hit, with Freddie Mac recording Pretax Losses as follows: $44.6 bil in 2008, $22.4 bil in 2009, $14.9 bil in 2010.

So while these losses are just huge, the one positive aspect is that they were declining sharply from the massive 2008 Loss.

And then in the 1Q 2011, this positive trend continued, with Freddie Mac actually generating a Pretax Income of $.6 bil, a complete reversal from its 1Q 2010 Pretax Loss of $6.8 bil.

But that’s the best it gets.

In the 2Q 2011, Freddie Mac recorded a Pretax Loss of $2.4 bil, which was a reduction from the much higher Loss of $5.0 bil in the 2Q 2010.

And now in the most recent 3Q 2011, Freddie Mac recorded a $4.5 bil Loss, which was 89% higher than the 2Q 2011 Loss of $2.4 bil. And this 3Q 2011 $4.5 bil Loss was 53% higher than the 3Q 2010 Loss of $2.9 bil.

From its SEC filings, below here is a very condensed summary of Freddie Mac’s Income Statements for the 3Q 2011, as compared with the 3Q 2010.

................................................................................Increase
...................................................3Q...........3Q........(Decrease)
.................................................2011.......2010....Amount......%
................................................(millions of dollars)

Net Interest Income................4,613......4,279........334.........8%
Provision for Credit Losses....(3,606)...(3,727)........121.........3%
Derivative Losses.............(4,752)...(1,130)..(3,622)..(321)%
Impairment of AFS
…Investment Securities............(161)....(1,100).......939.......85%
Other Loss on Inv Sec...............(541)......(503)........(38).......(8)%
Administrative Expenses..........(381)......(388)............7........2%
Other-net..................................350........(353).......703.....199%

Pretax Loss...........................(4,478)...(2,922)...(1,556).....(53)%

Clearly, the Losses are driven by the Derivative Losses.

In fact, absent the 3Q 2011 Derivative Losses of $4.8 bil, Freddie Mac would have recorded a Pretax Profit of $.3 bil. And the massive $3.6 bil Derivative Loss increase from the 3Q 2010, was $2.0 bil greater than the $1.6 bil increase in the Total Pretax Loss from the 3Q 2010.

And below here is a very condensed summary of Freddie Mac’s Income Statements for the lst 9 months Sept 2011, as compared with the lst 9 months 2010.

..............................................9 Mos....9 Mos.....Increase
..............................................Sept.......Sept.....(Decrease)
..............................................2011......2010.....Amount.......%
..............................................(millions of dollars)

Net Interest Income...........13,714......12,540......1,174........9%
Provision for
...Credit Losses..............(8,124)....(14,152)....6,028......43%
Derivative Losses.........(8,986)....(9,653).......667.......7%
Impairment of AFS
…Investment Securities.....(1,706).....(2,038).......332.......16%
Other Losses on Inv Sec........(452).....(1,176)........724.......62%
Administrative Expenses....(1,126).....(1,197).........71.........6%
Other-net................................433.........963.........530.......55%

Pretax Loss........................(6,247)..(14,713).....8,466.......58%

Yeah, for the first nine months of 2011, the prior year Pretax Loss was reduced by $8.5 bil.

What’s caused this Loss reduction?

Well, it’s mainly a $6.0 bil reduction in the Provision for Credit Losses. That takes away a great deal from the quality of the Pretax Loss reduction.

Also, it’s a $1.2 bil increase in Net Interest Income.

Further, it’s a $1.1 bil reduction in impairment and losses on its massive Investment Securities portfolio.

I think it would be wise to take a longer term look at Freddie Mac’s income statements: just before, during, and after the financial meltdown. But then I guess for Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, the financial meltdown is still going on.

From SEC filings, below here is a very condensed summary of Freddie Mac’s Income Statements for 2006 through 2011.

.....................9 Mos...Annual...Annual..Annual..Annual..Annual
.....................2011.....2010......2009.....2008.....2007.....2006
………….….............................(millions of dollars)………………......

Int Income..75,644.109,956..40,346..41,477..42,910..42,264
Int Exp.......(61,349)(92,131)(22,150)(33,332)(38,482)(37,270)
Derivative
..Expense........(581)....(969)...(1,123)..(1,349)...(1,329)..(1,582)
=Net Int Inc.13,714..16,856..17,073....6,796....3,099.....3,412
Prov for Credit
..Losses.......(8,124)(17,218)(29,530)(16,432)...(2,854)....(296)
Derivative
..Losses.......(8,986).(8,085)..(1,900).(14,954)..(1,904)..(1,173)
Gain(Loss) on
..Investment
..Securities.(2,158)..(5,560)..(5,232).(16,181).......294.....(473)
Mgt & Guaranty
…Income.....................143.....3,033.....3,370....2,635....2,393
Gain(Loss) on
…Guranteed
...Assets.......................(61)....3,299...(7,091)...(1,484)....(978)
Income on
..Guaranteed
..Obligations................135....3,479.....4,826.....1,905.....1,519
Low Income
..Housing Tax
..Credit................................(4,155).....(453)......(469).....(407)
Loss on Loans
…Purchased..................25..(4,754)...(1,634)...(1,865).....(148)
Security Admin
..Loss on
..Invests............................................(1,082)
Losses on
..Certain Credit
..Guarantees..........................................(17)....(1,988)....(406)
Foreign Currency
…Gains(Losses)................................................(2,348)........96
Admin
..Exps....(1,126)...(1,546)...(1,651)...(1,505)....(1,674)...(1,641)
Other-net..433........429....(2,046).....(207)........676........384
=Pretax
..Income
..(Loss).(6,247).(14,882)(22,384).(44,564)....(5,977)....2,282

In analyzing the above income statements, I have several comments.

First, look how much Net Interest Income jumped in 2009 to $17.1 bil, from $6.8 bil in 2008. I wonder if that is related, at least in part, to the subsidy the US Government granted to Freddie Mac to put them in a better financial situation. Clearly, it is not an economic gain earned from Freddie Mac’s operations, even though it is reflected in Freddie Mac’s bottom line.

Second, prior to 2007, there were just meager Provision for Credit Losses, charged to annual earnings. Let me lay these out for the past decade:

2000…........$79 mil
2001…...…..$32 mil
2002…….....$12 mil
2003….…...$(5) mil
2004…...…$143 mil
2005….....$307 mil
2006….....$296 mil
2007.....$2,854 mil
2008...$16,432 mil
2009...$29,530 mil
2010...$17,218 mil
2011.....$8,124 mil*

* 9 Months ended Sept 2011

Frankly, it doesn’t make sense to me why the Provisions for Credit Losses were so low before the financial meltdown. The amounts of Loans and Loan Guarantees were massive. Certainly more than these above meager amounts of bad loans should have been provided for.

Also, it seems to me that the 2008 Provision for Credit Losses of $16.4 bil is low. The massive financial meltdown occurred in 2008, but yet the following year's Provision was $13 bil higher than that provided in 2008. There is no logical match with when the loans should have been determined to be bad, and when the Provisions for Credit Losses were booked.

Likewise, the $17 bil additional Provision in 2010 seems really strange to me. So, the economic damage in the real estate market was more pronounced in 2010 than it was in 2008? That’s crazy.

Further, I think the real economic damage of these Loans is much less in 2011 than the huge Provision for Credit Losses booked in that year.

And third, and most important of all, what in the world is going on with all of these massive Derivative Losses. Let me lay them out since 2004.

...........Derivative...Derivative...Total Cost of
..............Losses.......Expenses....Derivatives
...............(millions of dollars)

2004.....4,475..........(100)............4,375
2005.....1,321..........1,058............2,379
2006.....1,173..........1,582............2,755
2007.....1,904.........1,329.............3,233
2008...14,954.........1,349...........16,303
2009.....1,900.........1,123............3,023
2010.....8,085...........969.............9,054
2011*....8,986...........581.............9,567

Total...42,798........7,891...........50,689

* 9 Months Sept 2011

Wasn’t it Albert Einstein who defined Insanity as “doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results”?

None of these years have Derivative Gains, and the total Derivative Losses are more than $50 bil!

If I understand this correctly, if Freddie Mac would not have engaged in any derivatives, it would have had higher earnings of more than $50 bil over the past 8 years.

I think the question the US Government should be asking is just who profited from these $50 bil of Derivative Losses, and how much money did they each make on them?

I think the US Government, including the US Congress and their staffs, have enough people working on the housing crisis, including reviewing what is going on with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.

But I also think the reason the housing crisis hasn’t been substantially improved, including the problems with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, is that the US Government doesn’t have enough very bright people, who also have the requisite financial expertise, who are working on these very complex housing crisis issues, so critical to improving the US economy, and US job creation.

The US Congress has done nothing of substance that effectively deals with the housing issue. And I think that all of the Feds responsible for reviewing, and taking wise subsequent actions on, what has been going on with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, haven’t effectively done their jobs.

The Occupy Movement, and their 99% supporters, are spot on in identifying the housing crisis as one where there clearly has not been enough progress made.

And just the thought of Freddie Mac throwing $50 bil away in the past 8 years by making bad, or at least less than optimal, Derivative decisions is enough to make the 99%ers intensely angry. Fannie Mae hasn't reported its 3Q 2011 Earnings yet, thus it should be interesting to see how their financial instrument hedging management program, or Derivatives, have worked out.

So the Deficit Reduction Super-committee is thinking of reducing Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security Benefits, while at the same time, not taking the proper actions to substantially reduce Freddie Mac's recurring, massive Derivative Losses? That's not right.....not even close to being right.

Saturday, November 5, 2011

Credit Card Earnings of US Big Financial Corps up 70% in 1st 9 Months of 2011, after being up $32 bil, or 1,819% in 2010

The Occupy Wall Street Protesters are dead on in singling out the 1% US Big Financial Corps which have Credit Card Operations. They have been bailed out by the US Government, and now their earnings are going through the roof.

Not so for their 99% customers. While the 99%ers are still suffering severely from the financial meltdown, they have been ripped off with very high interest rates charged and also exorbitant fees charged by the Big US Financial Corps with Credit Card Operations.

And the US Government continues to loan money to these Big US Financial Corps at extremely low interest rates.

It just doesn’t make any sense to the bright Occupy Wall Street Protesters.

They aren’t bailed out for their underwater mortgages, for their underwater education loans, or for their huge credit card loans. But yet the Big US Financial Corps, not only did get bailed out by the US Government, and continue to get extremely cheap financing from the US Government, but they also continue to get unreasonably high interest rate earnings from their 99% customers.....and that results in a huge, subsidized, favorable interest rate spread.

Something is seriously wrong here and has to be corrected.

Let me first present some research on just how well the Credit Card earnings have been for these Big US Financial Corps in the most recent two years.

In my recent post on US Big Credit Corps, I focused on the four large Credit Card Corps that are independent publicly-owned corporations: American Express, Visa, Discover Financial Services, and MasterCard. And since Capital One Financial generated 66% of its Total Revenues and 75% of its Total Profits in annual 2010 in its Credit Card Segment, I also included it with the other four.

Now in this post, I am adding to these above five US Big Credit Corps, the Credit Card Segment of three gigantic US Financial Corps, which have substantial Credit Card operations. These three Corps are Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, and Citigroup.

From their SEC filings, below here are the Pretax Income (PTI) for the first nine months of 2011, along with the previous year’s amounts, for all eight of these large US Financial Corps, including the PTI of only the Card Segment of these latter three huge US Financial Corps.

...............................................Pretax Income......
...........................................Nine Months Sept........Increase...
..............................................2011........2010......Amount....%
...............................................(millions of dollars)
Predominately Credit Card Corps
American Express.................5,208.......4,487..........721....16%
Visa......................................4,274.......3,430..........844....25%
Capital One Financial.............4,016.......3,297..........719....22%
MasterCard...........................2,758.......2,175..........583....27%
Discover Financial Services..2,694..........684........2,010..294%
Total of all 5........................18,950....14,073........4,877....35%

Card Segments of Huge Corps
Bank of America(1)...............7,519.......3,373.......4,146...123%
JP Morgan Chase..................5,746.......2,228.......3,518...158%
Citigroup(2).........................2,810..........935.......1,875...201%
Total of all 3.......................16,075.......6,536.......9,539...146%

Total of all 8.......................35,025....20,609......14,416....70%

(1) Bank of America 2010 PTI excludes $10.4 bil Goodwill Impairment Charge. If it were included, the above total % earnings increase would increase from 70% to 243%.
(2) Citigroup includes its Card operations with its Regional Consumer Banking Segment. The above earnings amounts are its after tax Net Income of its Card Operations, since it didn’t disclose its Pretax Income for its Card Operations.

Yeah, that’s correct, these 8 large US Financial Corps, generated $35.0 bil of Pretax Income from their Card Card Operations in the first 9 months of 2011, which was an increase of an incredible 70% over the prior year’s first 9 months amounts. And the real % earnings increase is even larger than 70%, because Citigroup only disclosed its after tax Net Income, which increased by 201% over the prior year.

And below here are the Pretax Income (PTI) or Pretax Loss (PTL) for annual 2010, along with the previous year 2009 amounts, for all eight of these large US Financial Corps, including the earnings of only the Card Segment of Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, and Citigroup.

...............................................PTI(L)......PTI(L)......Increase....
................................................2010........2009....Amount.....%
..................................................(millions of dollars)
Predominately Credit Card Corps
American Express...................5,964.......2,841.......3,123...110%
Visa........................................4,638.......3,527.......1,111......31%
Capital One Financial..............4,330.......1,336.......2,994...224%
Master Card............................2,757.......2,218.........539......24%
Discover Financial Services....1,269..........229.......1,040...454%
Total of all 5..........................18,958.....10,151.......8,807......87%

Card Segments of Huge Corps
Bank of America(1)................6,020......(8,233)....14,253....173%
JP Morgan Chase...................3,329......(3,539)......6,868....194%
Citigroup(2)..........................1,536..........(115)......1,651..1,436%
Total of all 3........................10,885.....(11,887)...22,772....192%

Total of all 8.........................29,843......(1,736)...31,579...1,819%

(1) Bank of America 2010 PTI excludes $10.4 bil Goodwill Impairment Charge.
(2) Citigroup includes its Card operations with its Regional Consumer Banking Segment. The above earnings amounts are its after tax Net Income of its Card Operations, since it didn’t disclose its Pretax Income for its Card Operations.

Yeah, that’s correct, these 8 large US Financial Corps, generated $29.8 bil of Pretax Income in 2010 from their Credit Card Operations, which was an increase of an incredible $31.6 bil, or 1,819% over 2009.

Now let me give a longer term view of what happened with these US Big Financial Corps, with substantial Credit Card Operations, just before, during, and after the financial meltdown.

Here's the Total Pretax Income* of the Credit Card Operations of these 8 US Big Credit Card Corps for the past 5 years:

2011 Annualized**....$46.7 bil, up 56% from 2010
2010.........................$29.8 bil, up 1,819% from 2009
2009........................$(1.7) bil, down 111% from 2008
2008........................$15.2 bil, down 47% from 2007
2007........................$28.5 bil

* Citigroup amounts included are its Net Income, rather than its Pretax Income.
** Nine months ended September 2011 actual Pretax Income annualized, except for Visa, which has a September fiscal year end.

So, these US Big Financial Corps, with substantial Credit Card Operations, along with their supporters in the US Congress (all Republicans and even some Democrats), are constantly whining about how the Obama Administration and Ben Bernanke have just devastated their industry?

Give me a break! This credit card industry was hurt by the financial meltdown. The Total Credit Card Earnings of these 8 Big Financial Corps declined from $28.5 bil in 2007 down to a loss of $(1.7) bil in 2009, or down by $30.2 bil in those two years.

But in only one year since 2009, this Total Loss of $(1.7) bil turned into a massive Total Profit of $29.8 bil, which exceeded its pre-financial meltdown earnings in 2007 of $28.5 bil. And for 2011, the nine-month actual annualized would be an even more massive $46.7 bil, or up an incredible $48.4 bil in those two years.

And their 2011 total nine-month annualized earnings of $46.7 bil are even an incredible 63% higher than they were in 2007, just before the financial meltdown hit.

I suggest that the 99%ers are the ones severely damaged, and not as yet even close to being made whole, by the financial meltdown, not the US Big Financial Corps with substantial Credit Card Operations.

There is a reason the Occupying Protesters are having such a positive impact. It's calling out the economic injustices like this one, and they are expecting the US Government to function properly and correct them.